Grades 10 and up- Mysterious and musically inclined, Bellweather Rhapsody brings the reader into the quaint world of the Bellweather Hotel in upstate New York. A hubbub of activity for years, the hotel's popularity has declined, but is busy one weekend a year due to the Statewide high school music competition. This year, Statewide happens to fall on the 15th anniversary of a murder-suicide at the hotel and someone is using this occasion to disturb the competition, in a deadly way.
I loved the constant perspective shift of the novel's quirky characters; there's Hastings who's run the concierge desk since before any of the other characters were born; Minnie Graves, who witnessed a murder-suicide at the hotel 15 years prior and has returned with her companion pooch to finally put to rest her inner demons; Alice and Bertram (Rabbit) Hatmaker, inseparable twin music geniuses; their pugnacious chaperone, "Weirdo" Wilson and a cast of wacky conductors and musical prima-donnas.
Reminiscing on my own high school band experience and the angst and anticipation of a hotel room with minimal adult supervision, I was drawn in immediately. As a sporadic reader of mysteries, I wasn't sure what to expect, but the variety of plot lines from teenage lust to haunted hotel rooms kept me hooked.
Although, this novel was written for adults. I think that the sharp wit of the characters and the constant forward motion of the mystery will engage young adults as well. VERDICT: While intriguing and just the right amount of strange, this novel should remain widely available at public libraries and accessible to curious high school readers.
I really enjoyed the book too. It took some unexpected directions, which I really enjoyed. I think it would go over the heads of junior high students, but I agree that many high schoolers would love it.
As I read this book I thought to myself "This reminds me of 'The Westing Game' that I read when I was a kid." Then in the acknowledgements the author thanked Ellen Raskin, author of "The Westing Game!" I thought that was really fun. Great story and I liked how the stories intertwined.
This book is written for students in Grade 8 and up. This book will appeal to anyone who loves to take a journey of survival and self discovery. The strength of books is that it gives the reader a sense of hope. Readers will be learning about how it feels to lose a limb and also learn about other disease such as cerebral palsy, facts and feelings and triumphs. I didn’t find any weakness in the book. The cover of the book is simple with the title of the books and a pair of running shoes. It fits perfectly with the story that is written. Verdict: The running dreams is a Winner of the Schneider Family Book Award. The books have an amazing story filled with hope and triumphs. It’s a page turner and a must in a library. It will give inspirations to the reader and feels like you are there as one of the character of the story.
I listened to this one and really enjoyed it. The narrator did a good job even though I usually don't like female narrators. When I was teaching I had several kids that were big into cross country. I was really able to hook them with this book. After they would finish it I would talk to them about what they thought. They really liked it and could relate to the main character a lot. I also liked that it gave them some experience with learning about people who have lost a limb. Many have never had that experience, so this will help them as they go on in life.
Great book. Well done. I too would put it in my library.
I was not expecting to enjoy this book because I don't like what often feels like emotional manipulation in tug at the heart stories of teens overcoming tragic accidents. I've been trying to figure out what made my reaction to this story different and possibly it was the fact that I listened to it rather than read it. I felt a bit more like I was hearing Jessica tell her own tale and I never felt like crying over her experience - it was all pretty upbeat. The upbeat "after school special" level of optimism was just what I needed while going through my own radiation treatment so the timing for listening to this one was good.
That upbeat feel is also a weakness of the book in my opinion. It sets a very unrealistic timeline for dealing with the loss of a limb and Jessica's ability to adapt to a prosthetic leg as fast as she did was unbelievable.
I was also bothered by the solution that Jessica found to help people see Rosa for who she is and not her disability. Pushing her in a balloon covered wheelchair while people wave from the side of the street doesn't really help them to know her.
As long as I'm nitpicking, the book would have been elevated in substance if the author had resolved the story line of the insurance claim and the money issues involved. I found that interesting and added a more realistic element to the "after school special" feel.
On the whole, however, I agree that this is a good book and would recommend it for grades 5 and up.
I also read "The Running Dream" by Wendelin Van Draanen
I agree with Lori about this book appealing to grades 5 and up. Particularly those dealing with an obstacle in their life and like Jill said those who are into track or cross country might especially enjoy this book.
Strengths: The message in the book sends positive energy to the reader which makes it a "feel good" novel. The optimism that Jessica's best friend, Fiona, has is admirable and sets a good example of what it looks like to be there for a friend in times of struggle. Love, family, optimism, perseverance, and friends are all themes presented in a positive light in the book. There is nothing controversial about the material contained in this book.
Weaknesses: I agree with Lori about the timeline of Jessica's recovery. I worry that it would give others in the same situation an unrealistic timeline of recovery after such an accident. I agree as well the money/insurance situation that Jessica's family was dealing with was never fully resolved. I am also unsure what part Lucy's mother had in the book. Her character seemed to appear just so some dialog could be added between Jessica and her overcoming her situation. However, I am unsure if the character was necessary just seemed more of a distraction for me.
Verdict: A positive, safe, uplifting book that many young adults can relate to and be inspired from. I would recommend adding multiple copies of this novel to any elementary, middle, or high school collection.
Crossing the Wire by Will Hobbs is a fictional adventure story about a young man who emigrates illegally from Mexico to the United States. Young Victor Flores is motivated to make the dangerous journey north across the border in order to support his widowed mother and three younger siblings. Hobbs is a seasoned writer of action adventure stories for young adults. This story will appeal to both middle and high school students alike, especially those with a personal immigration experience or to those who have connections to others who have immigrated to the United States.
The book’s strength lies in the turmoil, reflection, and personal sacrifice Victor undergoes to make a decision to leave and to trust others along the way. This is book captures the head and the heart of the matter people face when they decide to leave the familiar and take great risks to improve their future. Hobbs’ ability to put the reader in the scene is outstanding. In addition to action and suspense, Hobbs’ descriptions of the mountain and desert terrain provide a vicarious experience to the reader. Best of all the fictional account of Victor humanizes the experience, eliciting empathy for illegal immigrants’ situations.
A fair criticism of the book may include a stab at the authenticity of the story. How can a middle age white man, a former English Language Arts teacher, write about the harrowing experience of a young Mexican émigré? Mr. Hobbs did extensive research to write the book. He hiked the region, interviewed a variety of people—Border Patrol agents, immigrants, and coyotes (people smugglers). His experience working with young people put him in touch with the optimism and idealism and bravery young people possess. While he may not have lived this experience directly, his writing helps recreate a realistic journey based on truths gained from research and interviews.
Special Considerations: The novel reveals the importance of Victor’s faith in the journey. Before departing, he prays at church and asks for safe passage. He carries a token with the image of the Virgin of Guadalupe in his pocket. Devotion to one’s faith and family are tantamount.
Verdict: Illegal immigration is a complicated issue. Many young adult readers may think the issue is cut and dry; however this novel has the power to change some hearts and minds. Readers craving a good action-adventure story will be satisfied by Victor’s treacherous journey north and perhaps a few readers will begin to appreciate the complexities illegal immigration and the plight of humanity at the heart of it. A choice book for the library media center collection.
Through reading this book, I found myself bored by the language and writing style, especially since I read it on the tail of Code Name Verity. I think this book does a fine job telling the story, but will not appeal much to advanced readers. It would make a great high-low book to grab those struggling readers though!
It is always curious to see the age discrepancies between SLJ and publisher product reviews. While the product details cite an age range of 8-12 years (grades 3-7), SLJ lists it as Grades 5-8. I would tend to agree that middle school is a more appropriate audience, but that mature or G/T 3rd or 4th graders, as well as high school and adult students, would enjoy reading this book.
The plot line revolves around Teddy Fitzroy, who lives on-site at a zoo / amusement park called FunJungle. His mother works with the gorillas, and his dad is a traveling photographer, so Teddy is often left to wander the zoo during the summer, getting into all sorts of mild mischief. The mystery element comes in when the park's mascot (Henry the Hippo) turns up dead, and Teddy takes it upon himself to solve the crime. Along the way, he is dragged into a variety of semi-mature scenes including an animal autopsy, being attacked by tigers and snakes, and a gruesome hippo funeral, before solving the case.
Strengths of the book include a deep look into animal rights and treatment within theme parks, as well as with poaching and transport. Also, the book is packed with humorous and often ironic bits, such as Teddy providing water balloon ammo to the monkeys, to throw back at tourists, who deserve it after all the garbage they try to feed them.
The only weakness is that younger readers may find it difficult to keep up with all the park worker suspects (I did!), and that parts of the animal crime are gruesome and may scare or disgust certain readers.
Special considerations are the rural Texas setting, which reminded me of the excavations in Jurassic Park 1, as well as the fact that Gibbs is cranking out FunJungle novels very quickly, yet maintaining quality. The sequels (Poached and Big Game) are flying off the shelves just as quickly as Belly Up.
Verdict: A worthwhile inclusion for middle and high school collections, but be sure to stock multiple copies. Great option for a 5-8 book club or lit circle.
I read this book several years ago and really enjoyed it! I agree with all you say about it's strength. For my animal lovers I think it would be a great book for them because they could really connect to the story. But I also gave it to students who wanted a true mystery because the mystery was very well done!
E. Lockhart’s mysterious coming of age novel begins with Cadence Sinclair Eastman in her seventeenth summer on her family’s private estate, Beechwood Island. The novel bounces back and forth between this summer and “summer fifteen” during which a mysterious accident has happened that she can barely recollect. The book is a series of half remembered moments in her quest to figure out what happened before her accident.
Intended audience: Similar to E. Lockhart’s Printz winning novel The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau-Banks and John Green’s Looking for Alaska, this novel is definitely geared towards a upper-middle-class white high school audience. The setting is a private island near Martha’s Vineyard and its character's cousins who are living off the wealth of their bigoted grandfather.
Audience to whom it may appeal: Although the references often feel a bit highfalutin, the characters still cope with some of the same issues many teens do including: the desire to be autonomous of their parents, wanting to right worldly injustices, and falling in love with the one person their family disapproves of. I think male and female high schoolers of various backgrounds, as well as adults, could find connections, if minimal, in this novel.
Strengths: Given the mysterious nature of Cadence’s accident, I found the book to be a quick read because I wanted to find out what happened. Some strengths of the story include: memorable characters, descriptive setting language, and an engaging plot line with a haunting climax. I also appreciated "the liars'” self-awareness of privilege and their willingness to challenge their grandfather’s bigotry.
Weaknesses: This novel seems geared towards a very specific audience with little invitation for those with varying socioeconomic and racial backgrounds. Knowledge of the privilege lived by those who have experienced “life on the vineyard” seems relatively critical to understanding and enjoying the novel. I imagine this book on a "take a book, leave a book" shelf at the country club I worked at for many summers.
VERDICT: Although the book seems to have a minute intended audience, the mystery of it has the potential to appeal to a wider audience. I would include one copy of this novel in a high school library and promote it as a “haunting mystery about a teenage girl living in a dreamlike state on the fantasy world of her family's private island."
I just posted about this book too then I saw your post. I thought that it would appeal to a large audience despite the socioeconomic status of the characters. Not everyone would relate to the characters, but they could appreciate the mystery.
Violet has the ability to sense dead bodies whether it's those of animals or people. It's an ability she has kept hidden from everyone except her family and very close friends. Only now that ability is pulling her into a town mystery.
I really liked both Violet and Jay. They seemed "real". And what I really liked was their relationship was it also seemed realistic for a high school romance. For once in a long long time the main characters in the book didn't fall in love after only knowing each other for a few days. It was awesome to see how they had been friends for so long and only now were developing feelings. Violets actions towards Jay were perfect as she realized she had feelings for him. She didn't know what to do with those feelings, so as she struggled with that she did very typical teenage things. She ignored them, over reacted because of them, and became genuinely confused. It was perfect.
I also liked how Violet dealt with her "ability". I have no clue how anyone would deal with it, but that fact that she kept it almost low key and not consuming her life seemed the perfect way to handle it. The way Jay dealt with it was perfect as well. He was there for her whenever she needed it, but he didn't push her to do or say more than she was ready. He just accepted the way she was and moved on from it. Don't we all need a friend like that???
I really liked the mystery in the story. I was kept guessing about who the serial killer was and how everything was being done. I especially liked how the point of view would switch to the killer sometimes. That gave some very creepy insight into his mind. It really built the tension. I also liked how the tension came and went, so you always felt kind of off balance. Could you trust that everything was ok or did you still have to worry? Perfect for keeping me turning the pages. The ending wrapped everything up nicely, so you could stop reading the series after this one. There wasn't one of those maddening cliff hangers! But honestly I don't know what you'd stop after this one!
If you have any students who have recently dealt with a death or if there has been a death in your school community this might now be the best book for them. Also if the reader doesn't like being scared or nervous, they might want to pass.
This is the first book in a longer series, so it's a great starter for those who struggling finding something to read because they can continue on with the series.
Final thought: Great mystery and one I would add to the library.
Mr. Tucket is about a boy named Frances Tucket. He and his family are headed out west along the Oregon trail with many other families. On his 14th birthday, he receives a rifle. While out shooting in the distance from his wagon train, Frances is abducted by Pawnee Indians. The book goes on to describe Frances' account of being a captive in this tribe. Later, the Pawnee take Frances to see Mr. Grimes. Mr. Grimes is a self-described arms dealer to the Pawnee. Mr. Grimes uses his upstanding relationship to rescue Frances from the Pawnee. Mr. Grimes teaches Mr. Tucket many life lessons and lessons about living in the wild. In the end, there's a showdown between the Mr. Grimes and the Pawnee leader, Braid. Mr. Tucket becomes a man with only Mr. Grimes to thank for his transformation.
Strengths: Paulsen's descriptions of the characters and countryside are so vivid and entertaining. The ending makes you excited for the next book! I am truly amazed at the way Paulsen brings this Western to life!
Weaknesses: At times, this book seems rushed. I imagine that the book is rushed due to the audience of this book. It's a very quick read that most young middle schoolers won't be intimidated by its short chapters. This book could be better with more gritty details. I would like to see more action.
Verdict: Great book for young middle schoolers. Eighth graders and older would rather pick up a Louis L'Amour book with a bit more content and possibly more blood and action.
I would have these in the media center for sure as well! They are great for the middle school level for kids who are more reluctant readers because they are so fast paced and short. I know there are some editions where the books have been bound together, so if you have a student who doesn't want to have to keep getting the next one could read that, but for most kids I would recommend them to - the single book at a time would be perfect. And I also agree that beyond 8th grader they would pick up something different.
Jessica, the main character looses her leg in an accident and thinks she will never run again. She has many obstacles to overcome including learning to walk with a prosthetic and going back to school when she feels like everyone is staring at her. Jessica sits in the back of math class at a table because she is in a wheelchair and makes friends with Rosa who has Cerebral Palsy. In the past, Jessica has barely noticed Rosa, however after spending time with Rosa, Jessica learns an important lesson----it is more important to see the whole person and not just their disability. Through Jessica’s friendship with Rosa, and much determination to overcome obstacles, Jessica is able to overcome her disability and learn to walk and run again.
Audience for whom the book is written: This book is written for grades 6-12 based on language and style of writing. This book may appeal to adults as well who either have a child who needs to find strength in a difficult situation or may find they need strength to overcome a difficult situation themselves.
Strengths: Jessica has the support of her family, friends and a special friend Fiona as she struggles with learning how to walk and run again with her prosthesis. The story clearly details her struggles with rehabilitation. The book is cleverly written to show how Jessica initially feels sorry for herself and is withdrawn at the beginning of the book and slowly, step-by-step she begins to pick up the pieces. Jessica showed courage, determination and strength throughout the book in dealing with her disability.
Weaknesses: The story is emotional as Jessica initially in the story is wondering if she wants to continue life without her leg. It is a tearjerker!
Special Considerations: This would be a good book because it shows that no matter what your disability, someone else may have a more difficult time than you.
Verdict: A must have for your school library. It is an inspirational book. A good role model for young adults to see it is possible to overcome dealing with a tragic event.
“We Were Liars” by E. Lockhart is a thrilling mystery/suspense novel with a twist ending that will haunt readers. It is about Cadence and her extended and very wealthy family. Each year the whole extended family spends the summer on their private island. The summer Cady is fifteen she suffers a mysterious accident that makes her lose her memory and suffer from horrible migraines. When she is seventeen she returns to the island where—bit by bit—memories of what actually happened to her come to her. Filled with dysfunctional family drama, prejudice, greed, and romance, the ending of “We Were Liars” will shock most readers. Written of middle and high school age readers, this novel will especially appeal to Lockhart’s fans and those that like contemporary mysteries that are not predictable.
Strengths: This modern, psychological mystery can be disorienting because of the unreliable narrator. But the narrator—with her memory loss and hallucinations—makes the mystery even more thrilling. The spare, precise, and lyrical prose is perfect for Cady. The modern setting and interest in the life of a dysfunctional family with a lot of old money adds to the intrigue. And the ending…the ending that most readers will not see coming truly is a surprise.
Weaknesses: The unreliable narrator and jumping around in time can be disorienting for some. The author also uses a story of a king and his three daughters throughout the novel as a metaphor, which may be confusing to some readers.
Special Considerations: This book, with its summer setting, would be a great suggestion for summer reading.
Verdict: I think this is a strong purchase for middle and high school libraries. Lockhart’s previous novels include a Printz honor and National Book Award finalist. While this story is unlike any other she has written, her talent as a storyteller is apparent in “We Were Liars.”
"Escape from Mr. Lemoncello's Library" By Chris Grabenstein
This book would appeal to grades 5 and up. Particularly, those students who enjoy the silliness of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and the Phantom Tollbooth. For students looking for a puzzling, fun, interactive, page turner this book is for them!
Strengths: Strengths and special considerations include the educational value. The Dewey Decimal System is referenced throughout the book and numerous book, movie, and song titles are intertwined into the storyline. This provides excitement for those who recognize this and entices those who do not to read/view/listen to the referenced materials. This is a page turner, quick read, and is puzzling all at the same time. In the book there is an actual riddle that you have to flip through the pages to figure out. So cool!
Weaknesses: The protagonist, Kyle, is hard to truly connect with. The fast pace excitement revolving around the "game" or big puzzle takes away from the character development. There are times were you are rooting for him to win, but i'm not sure if I just wanted the puzzle to be solved or if I truly cared if it was Kyle that won or not.
Verdict: This mystery action packed novel would fly off the shelves of any elementary or middle school collection. Chris Grabenstein is a clever genius!
The Fixer (#1 in a planned series) Jennifer Lynn Barnes
A good mystery/thriller is one of my favorite "me" times. I cracked this book at 7 PM one night and read until 1:30 just to get to the end. I was using an e-reader so I didn’t really have a concept of the length. Keep in mind that I don’t enjoy thrillers with gratuitous violence so this teen version of a murder mystery set in the political world of Washington DC was right up my alley. The book is targeted to the 13-18 year old range but it could easily be enjoyed by mystery lovers in an elementary school. There are a few swear words (accompanied by disdainful glances to show disapproval) but the content is in no way shocking or inappropriate for younger readers. I would put it on par with the Alex Rider series by Horowitz. Some reviewers have mentioned Pretty Little Liars as a comparison.
Strengths – a Teen will find the storyline compelling. It didn’t have the grip of a Vince Flynn or a Brad Thor novel but it had the right pace and just enough plot twist so that it wasn’t predictable. The content is timely in that the plot revolves around the death of a Supreme Court Justice. The Ambassador of Iceland plays a small role which made me chuckle in light of the recent resignation of their Prime Minister amid the Panama Papers fallout. Just as compelling as the story are the characterization in this book. Tess Kendrick has sass and spirit, her sister Ivy is controlled and powerful. The minor characters have quirks that make them irritating at times but likable.
Weaknesses – Its light weight. The topics of Alzheimer’s, Supreme Court appointments, political game playing, child abuse, and the privileges of wealth and power are all there but none of them are explored. They are merely props for the story and if all you want is a good mystery, they make good props. The content isn’t there to teach any life lessons or make any social statements. The writing isn’t bad by any means but by the end of the book I was skipping over the repetitive things in italics – Tess’s internal thoughts. They just got to be irritating, as if the author was trying too hard to make sure the reader gets the point that Tess thinks things through and analyzes information. Tess thinks things through and the italics highlight her inner thoughts.
Special considerations – As with any mystery, the sequence of events and the details are critical to the plot and this would be a good book to use in a discussion of inference, deductive reasoning and prediction. Barnes has written other series so getting a student hooked on one, will lead to others.
Verdict: This is a definite add for a middle school collection but plan for the series as well. Beyond middle school, consider your audience and reading levels. This isn’t the BEST of the genre but its good and since it is a new series, your students probably haven’t read it yet.
The Secrets We Keep By: Trisha Leaver Genre: YA Mystery Published: April 2015
Recommended Rdg: Grades 7+
Summary: Maddy and Ella are identical twins. High School students discovering that appearances may be the only thing that makes them identical. Maddy is popular, social and a star athlete. Ella is quiet, shy and artistic. A terrible car accident takes the life of one of the girls...or does it? In her grief, Ella assumes the life of her dead sister, Maddy. Is life really greener on the other side or will she discover a secret life?
Strengths: Readers will instantly connect with the characters and the day-to-day struggles of trying to find yourself in the eyes of your family and peers. The story keeps the reader on edge with every twist and turn of the plot.
Weaknesses: At first I thought this was going to be a very predictable read. It is not. Stay with the story. The ending feels rushed compared to the rest of the story but it does come full circle.
Verdict: This would be an excellent book to have in your High School Media Center. Although it is recommended for grades 7+, I feel that the twisted plot may be a bit too confusing for a younger, middle school, reader. The story is clean (free from issues of language or sex) but given the age of the characters and the depths of emotional discovery, I feel it would be a best fit in a High School.
(OMG. I've read everyone else's reviews and always notice a synopsis, but have never given my own. Sorry. How dumb am I?)
Mick is a high school freshman looking to make the varsity football team. He is an excellent running back and shows all the skill to lead his team to victory. His dad had a brief stint in the NFL and has groomed Mick into the player he is. Football is all Mick thinks about. He wants to be the best and works hard to achieve his goals. However, he meets someone who introduces him to the world of steroids and Mick becomes hooked...
Audience: grades 8+
Appeals to: I think boys would really enjoy this book.
Strengths: I liked the passion in this story. When someone is passionate about something (i.e. a sport) it's intrigues me and I find myself wanting to know more about it. The way Mick feels about football is contagious. His motivation and determination were inspirational. I completely connected with the characters. The author did a great job making that happen. Also, I think that a lot of male, teen readers, will be able to relate with Mick. The sports side as well as the steroid connection. Many have probably heard or had some desire to do anything that would help them win.
Weaknesses: The story was very predictable. From the first part in the story, I "knew" how the story would play out.
Verdict: I think this is a definite must have for a middle and high school collection. It's a great read and would be of interest to reluctant readers as well as a male audience. The football theme will grab interest, but it's the steroid part that will keep the interest. Either way, it's a book that would be beneficial to have.
To whom would this book appeal? Breakaway would most appeal to students in grades 5-8. Soccer players would likely find the book most appealing, but there is enough of a story line that non-soccer players may find it an enjoyable read. Due to the central character being a female, girls will be drawn to the book more so than boys.
Summary: Twelve-year old Lily plays soccer with a passion and is one of the top young players in her town of Brookville. Breakaway takes the reader on Lily’s journey through a soccer season as well as a series of personal dilemmas. While family, friendships, and choices are all pieces to the story, the soccer focus is a strong component throughout. In the end, Lily’s journey teaches her that teamwork is important, both on and off the field.
Strengths: For students who are interested in soccer, there is a great deal of soccer action within the story. Anyone interested in sports in general will likely appreciate the references to teamwork and athleticism as well as the “edge-of-your seat” nature of some of the passages in the book. The book does a nice job of incorporating other important lessons/ topics such as: family responsibilities, peer relationships, learning from one’s mistakes, and confidence.
Weaknesses: At times, the lectures from coach and parents seem a little too “after-school-special” or “preachy” and may turn off some readers (particularly readers on the older end of the intended audience.) The ending is somewhat abrupt and predictable. It is a tidy book in that “it all works out in the end” which perhaps negates some of the lessons that the author intended.
Special considerations: There is a somewhat deeper exploration of family and social status. Lily’s family is unique in that they are a very middle class family living in an upper class community. There are references to her family’s Italian background, and for a portion of the book, her elderly grandfather (an “old school” Italian) comes to live with them. Lily’s best friend Vee plays on the same soccer team but lives in a poor suburb outside of Brookville. Lily notes how others in Brookville treat Vee, which leads Lily to do some soul-searching about her own place within the social circles of Brookville.
Verdict: I would include a copy or two of this book in an elementary school library as well as a middle school library. It is important to include books featuring girls playing sports. In addition, Breakaway causes the tween/teen reader to reflect on how we treat one another and some of the relational/ peer considerations that are so pertinent to this stage in their lives.
Audience to whom it will appeal: Anyone who loves a well spun mystery/ghost story.
Strengths of Book: Hahn does a fantastic job of creating real, believable characters. The main character, thirteen year-old Daniel Anderson deals with the sudden move of his family from an affluent life in Connecticut to a rundown farmhouse in the wilderness of West Virginia where danger lurks in the surrounding woods and in stories of Old Auntie by his new schoolmates. The ghost story is told with a folktale feel making it all the more believable. The point of view switches between Daniel and Old Auntie which builds eerie and ominous tones. Then Daniel's younger sister, Erica, starts becoming more withdrawn, talking to her doll, and speaking of a voice she hears. Are the stories at school true? Is there an Old Auntie who takes a little girl every fifty years and her scary resurrected razorback hog, Bloody Bones.
Weaknesses of Book: At some points the mystery is a bit predictable.
Special Considerations: The mysterious nature and magical qualities of Old Auntie may scare some readers.
Verdict: This book is a relatable read for middle schoolers who are fans of spooky stories. Readers will be able to relate to Daniel’s frustration that the adults in his life don’t take him seriously and don’t listen to him. The spookiness and suspenseful nature of the story is not so far over-the-top scary or violent that it is disturbing. I would definitely keep this in the middle school media center.
This book was written for high school girls, but I think it would appeal to upper middle school students as well. More specifically, female sports fans will enjoy the book, but I also think those who aren’t necessarily sports fans will go for it as well.
Strengths – The quality of the writing is good and the storyline is intriguing as it is about a biracial girl, African American and Caucasian, named Alex who was adopted as a baby by a Caucasian family. Her adopted father is a baseball fanatic and has been training her and her brother for years. Once Alex learns that her birth father has been writing her letters that her adoptive parents have kept from her, she begins to try to answer her questions about her birth family and even more importantly, she explores what it means to be African American. This is really the main plotline and the sports element becomes more of a subplot. Gibney handles both parts of the story well.
Alex is a strong character, realistically portrayed and quite likable as well. She enters into a relationship with an African American boy, Reggie, but doesn’t need to be saved by him. She prefers to work things out on her own.
Weaknesses – There may be a misleading notion that this is a sports book, even with the title. However, I do not see that as too much of a problem. There are plenty of sports scenes in the book to entertain the sports enthusiast.
Another possible issue with this book is that even with the suggestion of a sports theme, boys may still perceive this as a “girl’s” book which narrows the audience.
Special considerations - Alex and Reggie engage in sexual activities and there is some cursing as well. But more important, is the inner turmoil Alex is dealing with regarding her identity. She struggles with the fact that she is biracial having grown up in a white world. Meeting Reggie, she discovers how much she doesn’t know about the black perspective. She questions her place in the black community and begins to find herself and how she fits in. This book is certainly more about identity and self-perception than sports.
My verdict – Get this book for your high school library! A book with an athletic biracial female protagonist is just the text to support a multicultural library. It is a must-have for sure!
This story is about a boy (Julio junior) whose papi (Julio senior) flees Cuba to play professional baseball in the United States, when Junior is 10 years old. He's now 16 and baseball is his life. He'd love to play for the Cuba Nacionales. He's very angry with his father. Believing he's living a life of luxury while he had to quit school to work and his mother is a maid. The opportunity presents itself for Junior to flee Cuba and be with his papi. He's unsure if he should "abandon" his family like his father did...
Audience: Boys grades 6+
Appeals to: Youth, especially boys, interested in baseball. Possibly reluctant readers because the story is so interesting.
Strengths: It's an enjoyable read that keeps the attention of the reader with all of the action taking place throughout the story. The title of the book, sets the big scene in the story. Game seven of the world series. After it's over, will father and son be reunited? The book is full of passion-for the sport of baseball as well as family.
Weaknesses: It was a predictable read. The ending left me questioning.
Verdict: I think this is a must have for any middle school library. Boys will be drawn to a story like this, filled with sports and action. d
Bellweather Rhapsody by Kate Racculia
ReplyDeleteGrades 10 and up-
Mysterious and musically inclined, Bellweather Rhapsody brings the reader into the quaint world of the Bellweather Hotel in upstate New York. A hubbub of activity for years, the hotel's popularity has declined, but is busy one weekend a year due to the Statewide high school music competition. This year, Statewide happens to fall on the 15th anniversary of a murder-suicide at the hotel and someone is using this occasion to disturb the competition, in a deadly way.
I loved the constant perspective shift of the novel's quirky characters; there's Hastings who's run the concierge desk since before any of the other characters were born; Minnie Graves, who witnessed a murder-suicide at the hotel 15 years prior and has returned with her companion pooch to finally put to rest her inner demons; Alice and Bertram (Rabbit) Hatmaker, inseparable twin music geniuses; their pugnacious chaperone, "Weirdo" Wilson and a cast of wacky conductors and musical prima-donnas.
Reminiscing on my own high school band experience and the angst and anticipation of a hotel room with minimal adult supervision, I was drawn in immediately. As a sporadic reader of mysteries, I wasn't sure what to expect, but the variety of plot lines from teenage lust to haunted hotel rooms kept me hooked.
Although, this novel was written for adults. I think that the sharp wit of the characters and the constant forward motion of the mystery will engage young adults as well. VERDICT: While intriguing and just the right amount of strange, this novel should remain widely available at public libraries and accessible to curious high school readers.
Awards: Alex Award, 2015
I really enjoyed the book too. It took some unexpected directions, which I really enjoyed. I think it would go over the heads of junior high students, but I agree that many high schoolers would love it.
DeleteAs I read this book I thought to myself "This reminds me of 'The Westing Game' that I read when I was a kid." Then in the acknowledgements the author thanked Ellen Raskin, author of "The Westing Game!" I thought that was really fun. Great story and I liked how the stories intertwined.
DeleteThe Running Dreams by Wendelin Van Draanen
ReplyDeleteThis book is written for students in Grade 8 and up. This book will appeal to anyone who loves to take a journey of survival and self discovery. The strength of books is that it gives the reader a sense of hope. Readers will be learning about how it feels to lose a limb and also learn about other disease such as cerebral palsy, facts and feelings and triumphs. I didn’t find any weakness in the book. The cover of the book is simple with the title of the books and a pair of running shoes. It fits perfectly with the story that is written.
Verdict: The running dreams is a Winner of the Schneider Family Book Award. The books have an amazing story filled with hope and triumphs. It’s a page turner and a must in a library. It will give inspirations to the reader and feels like you are there as one of the character of the story.
I listened to this one and really enjoyed it. The narrator did a good job even though I usually don't like female narrators. When I was teaching I had several kids that were big into cross country. I was really able to hook them with this book. After they would finish it I would talk to them about what they thought. They really liked it and could relate to the main character a lot. I also liked that it gave them some experience with learning about people who have lost a limb. Many have never had that experience, so this will help them as they go on in life.
DeleteGreat book. Well done. I too would put it in my library.
I was not expecting to enjoy this book because I don't like what often feels like emotional manipulation in tug at the heart stories of teens overcoming tragic accidents. I've been trying to figure out what made my reaction to this story different and possibly it was the fact that I listened to it rather than read it. I felt a bit more like I was hearing Jessica tell her own tale and I never felt like crying over her experience - it was all pretty upbeat. The upbeat "after school special" level of optimism was just what I needed while going through my own radiation treatment so the timing for listening to this one was good.
DeleteThat upbeat feel is also a weakness of the book in my opinion. It sets a very unrealistic timeline for dealing with the loss of a limb and Jessica's ability to adapt to a prosthetic leg as fast as she did was unbelievable.
I was also bothered by the solution that Jessica found to help people see Rosa for who she is and not her disability. Pushing her in a balloon covered wheelchair while people wave from the side of the street doesn't really help them to know her.
As long as I'm nitpicking, the book would have been elevated in substance if the author had resolved the story line of the insurance claim and the money issues involved. I found that interesting and added a more realistic element to the "after school special" feel.
On the whole, however, I agree that this is a good book and would recommend it for grades 5 and up.
I also read "The Running Dream" by Wendelin Van Draanen
DeleteI agree with Lori about this book appealing to grades 5 and up. Particularly those dealing with an obstacle in their life and like Jill said those who are into track or cross country might especially enjoy this book.
Strengths:
The message in the book sends positive energy to the reader which makes it a "feel good" novel. The optimism that Jessica's best friend, Fiona, has is admirable and sets a good example of what it looks like to be there for a friend in times of struggle. Love, family, optimism, perseverance, and friends are all themes presented in a positive light in the book. There is nothing controversial about the material contained in this book.
Weaknesses:
I agree with Lori about the timeline of Jessica's recovery. I worry that it would give others in the same situation an unrealistic timeline of recovery after such an accident. I agree as well the money/insurance situation that Jessica's family was dealing with was never fully resolved. I am also unsure what part Lucy's mother had in the book. Her character seemed to appear just so some dialog could be added between Jessica and her overcoming her situation. However, I am unsure if the character was necessary just seemed more of a distraction for me.
Verdict:
A positive, safe, uplifting book that many young adults can relate to and be inspired from. I would recommend adding multiple copies of this novel to any elementary, middle, or high school collection.
Crossing the Wire by Will Hobbs is a fictional adventure story about a young man who emigrates illegally from Mexico to the United States. Young Victor Flores is motivated to make the dangerous journey north across the border in order to support his widowed mother and three younger siblings. Hobbs is a seasoned writer of action adventure stories for young adults. This story will appeal to both middle and high school students alike, especially those with a personal immigration experience or to those who have connections to others who have immigrated to the United States.
ReplyDeleteThe book’s strength lies in the turmoil, reflection, and personal sacrifice Victor undergoes to make a decision to leave and to trust others along the way. This is book captures the head and the heart of the matter people face when they decide to leave the familiar and take great risks to improve their future. Hobbs’ ability to put the reader in the scene is outstanding. In addition to action and suspense, Hobbs’ descriptions of the mountain and desert terrain provide a vicarious experience to the reader. Best of all the fictional account of Victor humanizes the experience, eliciting empathy for illegal immigrants’ situations.
A fair criticism of the book may include a stab at the authenticity of the story. How can a middle age white man, a former English Language Arts teacher, write about the harrowing experience of a young Mexican émigré? Mr. Hobbs did extensive research to write the book. He hiked the region, interviewed a variety of people—Border Patrol agents, immigrants, and coyotes (people smugglers). His experience working with young people put him in touch with the optimism and idealism and bravery young people possess. While he may not have lived this experience directly, his writing helps recreate a realistic journey based on truths gained from research and interviews.
Special Considerations: The novel reveals the importance of Victor’s faith in the journey. Before departing, he prays at church and asks for safe passage. He carries a token with the image of the Virgin of Guadalupe in his pocket. Devotion to one’s faith and family are tantamount.
Verdict: Illegal immigration is a complicated issue. Many young adult readers may think the issue is cut and dry; however this novel has the power to change some hearts and minds. Readers craving a good action-adventure story will be satisfied by Victor’s treacherous journey north and perhaps a few readers will begin to appreciate the complexities illegal immigration and the plight of humanity at the heart of it. A choice book for the library media center collection.
I have wanted to read this for a long time! I am excited to try it. Thanks for your thorough review!
DeleteThrough reading this book, I found myself bored by the language and writing style, especially since I read it on the tail of Code Name Verity. I think this book does a fine job telling the story, but will not appeal much to advanced readers. It would make a great high-low book to grab those struggling readers though!
DeleteBelly Up, by Stuart Gibbs
ReplyDeleteIt is always curious to see the age discrepancies between SLJ and publisher product reviews. While the product details cite an age range of 8-12 years (grades 3-7), SLJ lists it as Grades 5-8. I would tend to agree that middle school is a more appropriate audience, but that mature or G/T 3rd or 4th graders, as well as high school and adult students, would enjoy reading this book.
The plot line revolves around Teddy Fitzroy, who lives on-site at a zoo / amusement park called FunJungle. His mother works with the gorillas, and his dad is a traveling photographer, so Teddy is often left to wander the zoo during the summer, getting into all sorts of mild mischief. The mystery element comes in when the park's mascot (Henry the Hippo) turns up dead, and Teddy takes it upon himself to solve the crime. Along the way, he is dragged into a variety of semi-mature scenes including an animal autopsy, being attacked by tigers and snakes, and a gruesome hippo funeral, before solving the case.
Strengths of the book include a deep look into animal rights and treatment within theme parks, as well as with poaching and transport. Also, the book is packed with humorous and often ironic bits, such as Teddy providing water balloon ammo to the monkeys, to throw back at tourists, who deserve it after all the garbage they try to feed them.
The only weakness is that younger readers may find it difficult to keep up with all the park worker suspects (I did!), and that parts of the animal crime are gruesome and may scare or disgust certain readers.
Special considerations are the rural Texas setting, which reminded me of the excavations in Jurassic Park 1, as well as the fact that Gibbs is cranking out FunJungle novels very quickly, yet maintaining quality. The sequels (Poached and Big Game) are flying off the shelves just as quickly as Belly Up.
Verdict: A worthwhile inclusion for middle and high school collections, but be sure to stock multiple copies. Great option for a 5-8 book club or lit circle.
My 3rd-5th graders love this book! It won the Maud Hart Lovelace last year. IT's a fun one!
DeleteI loved this book too! It's pretty funny. I'm using it in class as a book club book this year.
DeleteI read this book several years ago and really enjoyed it! I agree with all you say about it's strength. For my animal lovers I think it would be a great book for them because they could really connect to the story. But I also gave it to students who wanted a true mystery because the mystery was very well done!
ReplyDeleteWe Were Liars by E. Lockhart
ReplyDeleteGrades 8 and up--
E. Lockhart’s mysterious coming of age novel begins with Cadence Sinclair Eastman in her seventeenth summer on her family’s private estate, Beechwood Island. The novel bounces back and forth between this summer and “summer fifteen” during which a mysterious accident has happened that she can barely recollect. The book is a series of half remembered moments in her quest to figure out what happened before her accident.
Intended audience: Similar to E. Lockhart’s Printz winning novel The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau-Banks and John Green’s Looking for Alaska, this novel is definitely geared towards a upper-middle-class white high school audience. The setting is a private island near Martha’s Vineyard and its character's cousins who are living off the wealth of their bigoted grandfather.
Audience to whom it may appeal: Although the references often feel a bit highfalutin, the characters still cope with some of the same issues many teens do including: the desire to be autonomous of their parents, wanting to right worldly injustices, and falling in love with the one person their family disapproves of. I think male and female high schoolers of various backgrounds, as well as adults, could find connections, if minimal, in this novel.
Strengths: Given the mysterious nature of Cadence’s accident, I found the book to be a quick read because I wanted to find out what happened. Some strengths of the story include: memorable characters, descriptive setting language, and an engaging plot line with a haunting climax. I also appreciated "the liars'” self-awareness of privilege and their willingness to challenge their grandfather’s bigotry.
Weaknesses: This novel seems geared towards a very specific audience with little invitation for those with varying socioeconomic and racial backgrounds. Knowledge of the privilege lived by those who have experienced “life on the vineyard” seems relatively critical to understanding and enjoying the novel. I imagine this book on a "take a book, leave a book" shelf at the country club I worked at for many summers.
VERDICT: Although the book seems to have a minute intended audience, the mystery of it has the potential to appeal to a wider audience. I would include one copy of this novel in a high school library and promote it as a “haunting mystery about a teenage girl living in a dreamlike state on the fantasy world of her family's private island."
I just posted about this book too then I saw your post. I thought that it would appeal to a large audience despite the socioeconomic status of the characters. Not everyone would relate to the characters, but they could appreciate the mystery.
DeleteTitle: The Body Finder
ReplyDeleteAuthor: Kimberly Derting
Violet has the ability to sense dead bodies whether it's those of animals or people. It's an ability she has kept hidden from everyone except her family and very close friends. Only now that ability is pulling her into a town mystery.
I really liked both Violet and Jay. They seemed "real". And what I really liked was their relationship was it also seemed realistic for a high school romance. For once in a long long time the main characters in the book didn't fall in love after only knowing each other for a few days. It was awesome to see how they had been friends for so long and only now were developing feelings. Violets actions towards Jay were perfect as she realized she had feelings for him. She didn't know what to do with those feelings, so as she struggled with that she did very typical teenage things. She ignored them, over reacted because of them, and became genuinely confused. It was perfect.
I also liked how Violet dealt with her "ability". I have no clue how anyone would deal with it, but that fact that she kept it almost low key and not consuming her life seemed the perfect way to handle it. The way Jay dealt with it was perfect as well. He was there for her whenever she needed it, but he didn't push her to do or say more than she was ready. He just accepted the way she was and moved on from it. Don't we all need a friend like that???
I really liked the mystery in the story. I was kept guessing about who the serial killer was and how everything was being done. I especially liked how the point of view would switch to the killer sometimes. That gave some very creepy insight into his mind. It really built the tension. I also liked how the tension came and went, so you always felt kind of off balance. Could you trust that everything was ok or did you still have to worry? Perfect for keeping me turning the pages. The ending wrapped everything up nicely, so you could stop reading the series after this one. There wasn't one of those maddening cliff hangers! But honestly I don't know what you'd stop after this one!
If you have any students who have recently dealt with a death or if there has been a death in your school community this might now be the best book for them. Also if the reader doesn't like being scared or nervous, they might want to pass.
This is the first book in a longer series, so it's a great starter for those who struggling finding something to read because they can continue on with the series.
Final thought: Great mystery and one I would add to the library.
Mr. Tucket by Gary Paulsen
ReplyDeleteGrades 6-9
Mr. Tucket is about a boy named Frances Tucket. He and his family are headed out west along the Oregon trail with many other families. On his 14th birthday, he receives a rifle. While out shooting in the distance from his wagon train, Frances is abducted by Pawnee Indians. The book goes on to describe Frances' account of being a captive in this tribe. Later, the Pawnee take Frances to see Mr. Grimes. Mr. Grimes is a self-described arms dealer to the Pawnee. Mr. Grimes uses his upstanding relationship to rescue Frances from the Pawnee. Mr. Grimes teaches Mr. Tucket many life lessons and lessons about living in the wild. In the end, there's a showdown between the Mr. Grimes and the Pawnee leader, Braid. Mr. Tucket becomes a man with only Mr. Grimes to thank for his transformation.
Strengths: Paulsen's descriptions of the characters and countryside are so vivid and entertaining. The ending makes you excited for the next book! I am truly amazed at the way Paulsen brings this Western to life!
Weaknesses: At times, this book seems rushed. I imagine that the book is rushed due to the audience of this book. It's a very quick read that most young middle schoolers won't be intimidated by its short chapters. This book could be better with more gritty details. I would like to see more action.
Verdict: Great book for young middle schoolers. Eighth graders and older would rather pick up a Louis L'Amour book with a bit more content and possibly more blood and action.
I would have these in the media center for sure as well! They are great for the middle school level for kids who are more reluctant readers because they are so fast paced and short. I know there are some editions where the books have been bound together, so if you have a student who doesn't want to have to keep getting the next one could read that, but for most kids I would recommend them to - the single book at a time would be perfect. And I also agree that beyond 8th grader they would pick up something different.
DeleteThe Running Dream
ReplyDeleteBy Wendelin Van Draanen
Jessica, the main character looses her leg in an accident and thinks she will never run again. She has many obstacles to overcome including learning to walk with a prosthetic and going back to school when she feels like everyone is staring at her. Jessica sits in the back of math class at a table because she is in a wheelchair and makes friends with Rosa who has Cerebral Palsy. In the past, Jessica has barely noticed Rosa, however after spending time with Rosa, Jessica learns an important lesson----it is more important to see the whole person and not just their disability. Through Jessica’s friendship with Rosa, and much determination to overcome obstacles, Jessica is able to overcome her disability and learn to walk and run again.
Audience for whom the book is written: This book is written for grades 6-12 based on language and style of writing. This book may appeal to adults as well who either have a child who needs to find strength in a difficult situation or may find they need strength to overcome a difficult situation themselves.
Strengths: Jessica has the support of her family, friends and a special friend Fiona as she struggles with learning how to walk and run again with her prosthesis. The story clearly details her struggles with rehabilitation. The book is cleverly written to show how Jessica initially feels sorry for herself and is withdrawn at the beginning of the book and slowly, step-by-step she begins to pick up the pieces. Jessica showed courage, determination and strength throughout the book in dealing with her disability.
Weaknesses: The story is emotional as Jessica initially in the story is wondering if she wants to continue life without her leg. It is a tearjerker!
Special Considerations: This would be a good book because it shows that no matter what your disability, someone else may have a more difficult time than you.
Verdict: A must have for your school library. It is an inspirational book. A good role model for young adults to see it is possible to overcome dealing with a tragic event.
“We Were Liars” by E. Lockhart
ReplyDelete“We Were Liars” by E. Lockhart is a thrilling mystery/suspense novel with a twist ending that will haunt readers. It is about Cadence and her extended and very wealthy family. Each year the whole extended family spends the summer on their private island. The summer Cady is fifteen she suffers a mysterious accident that makes her lose her memory and suffer from horrible migraines. When she is seventeen she returns to the island where—bit by bit—memories of what actually happened to her come to her. Filled with dysfunctional family drama, prejudice, greed, and romance, the ending of “We Were Liars” will shock most readers. Written of middle and high school age readers, this novel will especially appeal to Lockhart’s fans and those that like contemporary mysteries that are not predictable.
Strengths: This modern, psychological mystery can be disorienting because of the unreliable narrator. But the narrator—with her memory loss and hallucinations—makes the mystery even more thrilling. The spare, precise, and lyrical prose is perfect for Cady. The modern setting and interest in the life of a dysfunctional family with a lot of old money adds to the intrigue. And the ending…the ending that most readers will not see coming truly is a surprise.
Weaknesses: The unreliable narrator and jumping around in time can be disorienting for some. The author also uses a story of a king and his three daughters throughout the novel as a metaphor, which may be confusing to some readers.
Special Considerations: This book, with its summer setting, would be a great suggestion for summer reading.
Verdict: I think this is a strong purchase for middle and high school libraries. Lockhart’s previous novels include a Printz honor and National Book Award finalist. While this story is unlike any other she has written, her talent as a storyteller is apparent in “We Were Liars.”
"Escape from Mr. Lemoncello's Library" By Chris Grabenstein
ReplyDeleteThis book would appeal to grades 5 and up. Particularly, those students who enjoy the silliness of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and the Phantom Tollbooth. For students looking for a puzzling, fun, interactive, page turner this book is for them!
Strengths:
Strengths and special considerations include the educational value. The Dewey Decimal System is referenced throughout the book and numerous book, movie, and song titles are intertwined into the storyline. This provides excitement for those who recognize this and entices those who do not to read/view/listen to the referenced materials. This is a page turner, quick read, and is puzzling all at the same time. In the book there is an actual riddle that you have to flip through the pages to figure out. So cool!
Weaknesses:
The protagonist, Kyle, is hard to truly connect with. The fast pace excitement revolving around the "game" or big puzzle takes away from the character development. There are times were you are rooting for him to win, but i'm not sure if I just wanted the puzzle to be solved or if I truly cared if it was Kyle that won or not.
Verdict:
This mystery action packed novel would fly off the shelves of any elementary or middle school collection. Chris Grabenstein is a clever genius!
This and it's sequel are hugely popular with my 3rd-5th graders as it is a Maud Hart Lovelace nominee.
DeleteThe Fixer (#1 in a planned series)
ReplyDeleteJennifer Lynn Barnes
A good mystery/thriller is one of my favorite "me" times. I cracked this book at 7 PM one night and read until 1:30 just to get to the end. I was using an e-reader so I didn’t really have a concept of the length. Keep in mind that I don’t enjoy thrillers with gratuitous violence so this teen version of a murder mystery set in the political world of Washington DC was right up my alley. The book is targeted to the 13-18 year old range but it could easily be enjoyed by mystery lovers in an elementary school. There are a few swear words (accompanied by disdainful glances to show disapproval) but the content is in no way shocking or inappropriate for younger readers. I would put it on par with the Alex Rider series by Horowitz. Some reviewers have mentioned Pretty Little Liars as a comparison.
Strengths – a Teen will find the storyline compelling. It didn’t have the grip of a Vince Flynn or a Brad Thor novel but it had the right pace and just enough plot twist so that it wasn’t predictable. The content is timely in that the plot revolves around the death of a Supreme Court Justice. The Ambassador of Iceland plays a small role which made me chuckle in light of the recent resignation of their Prime Minister amid the Panama Papers fallout. Just as compelling as the story are the characterization in this book. Tess Kendrick has sass and spirit, her sister Ivy is controlled and powerful. The minor characters have quirks that make them irritating at times but likable.
Weaknesses – Its light weight. The topics of Alzheimer’s, Supreme Court appointments, political game playing, child abuse, and the privileges of wealth and power are all there but none of them are explored. They are merely props for the story and if all you want is a good mystery, they make good props. The content isn’t there to teach any life lessons or make any social statements. The writing isn’t bad by any means but by the end of the book I was skipping over the repetitive things in italics – Tess’s internal thoughts. They just got to be irritating, as if the author was trying too hard to make sure the reader gets the point that Tess thinks things through and analyzes information. Tess thinks things through and the italics highlight her inner thoughts.
Special considerations – As with any mystery, the sequence of events and the details are critical to the plot and this would be a good book to use in a discussion of inference, deductive reasoning and prediction. Barnes has written other series so getting a student hooked on one, will lead to others.
Verdict: This is a definite add for a middle school collection but plan for the series as well. Beyond middle school, consider your audience and reading levels. This isn’t the BEST of the genre but its good and since it is a new series, your students probably haven’t read it yet.
The Secrets We Keep
ReplyDeleteBy: Trisha Leaver
Genre: YA Mystery
Published: April 2015
Recommended Rdg: Grades 7+
Summary:
Maddy and Ella are identical twins. High School students discovering that appearances may be the only thing that makes them identical. Maddy is popular, social and a star athlete. Ella is quiet, shy and artistic. A terrible car accident takes the life of one of the girls...or does it? In her grief, Ella assumes the life of her dead sister, Maddy. Is life really greener on the other side or will she discover a secret life?
Strengths: Readers will instantly connect with the characters and the day-to-day struggles of trying to find yourself in the eyes of your family and peers. The story keeps the reader on edge with every twist and turn of the plot.
Weaknesses: At first I thought this was going to be a very predictable read. It is not. Stay with the story. The ending feels rushed compared to the rest of the story but it does come full circle.
Verdict: This would be an excellent book to have in your High School Media Center. Although it is recommended for grades 7+, I feel that the twisted plot may be a bit too confusing for a younger, middle school, reader. The story is clean (free from issues of language or sex) but given the age of the characters and the depths of emotional discovery, I feel it would be a best fit in a High School.
Gym Candy
ReplyDeleteby Carl Deuker
(OMG. I've read everyone else's reviews and always notice a synopsis, but have never given my own. Sorry. How dumb am I?)
Mick is a high school freshman looking to make the varsity football team. He is an excellent running back and shows all the skill to lead his team to victory. His dad had a brief stint in the NFL and has groomed Mick into the player he is. Football is all Mick thinks about. He wants to be the best and works hard to achieve his goals. However, he meets someone who introduces him to the world of steroids and Mick becomes hooked...
Audience: grades 8+
Appeals to: I think boys would really enjoy this book.
Strengths: I liked the passion in this story. When someone is passionate about something (i.e. a sport) it's intrigues me and I find myself wanting to know more about it. The way Mick feels about football is contagious. His motivation and determination were inspirational. I completely connected with the characters. The author did a great job making that happen. Also, I think that a lot of male, teen readers, will be able to relate with Mick. The sports side as well as the steroid connection. Many have probably heard or had some desire to do anything that would help them win.
Weaknesses: The story was very predictable. From the first part
in the story, I "knew" how the story would play out.
Verdict: I think this is a definite must have for a middle and high school collection. It's a great read and would be of interest to reluctant readers as well as a male audience. The football theme will grab interest, but it's the steroid part that will keep the interest. Either way, it's a book that would be beneficial to have.
Breakaway
ReplyDeleteBy Andrea Montalbano
Intended audience: grades 5-8
To whom would this book appeal? Breakaway would most appeal to students in grades 5-8. Soccer players would likely find the book most appealing, but there is enough of a story line that non-soccer players may find it an enjoyable read. Due to the central character being a female, girls will be drawn to the book more so than boys.
Summary: Twelve-year old Lily plays soccer with a passion and is one of the top young players in her town of Brookville. Breakaway takes the reader on Lily’s journey through a soccer season as well as a series of personal dilemmas. While family, friendships, and choices are all pieces to the story, the soccer focus is a strong component throughout. In the end, Lily’s journey teaches her that teamwork is important, both on and off the field.
Strengths: For students who are interested in soccer, there is a great deal of soccer action within the story. Anyone interested in sports in general will likely appreciate the references to teamwork and athleticism as well as the “edge-of-your seat” nature of some of the passages in the book. The book does a nice job of incorporating other important lessons/ topics such as: family responsibilities, peer relationships, learning from one’s mistakes, and confidence.
Weaknesses: At times, the lectures from coach and parents seem a little too “after-school-special” or “preachy” and may turn off some readers (particularly readers on the older end of the intended audience.) The ending is somewhat abrupt and predictable. It is a tidy book in that “it all works out in the end” which perhaps negates some of the lessons that the author intended.
Special considerations: There is a somewhat deeper exploration of family and social status. Lily’s family is unique in that they are a very middle class family living in an upper class community. There are references to her family’s Italian background, and for a portion of the book, her elderly grandfather (an “old school” Italian) comes to live with them. Lily’s best friend Vee plays on the same soccer team but lives in a poor suburb outside of Brookville. Lily notes how others in Brookville treat Vee, which leads Lily to do some soul-searching about her own place within the social circles of Brookville.
Verdict: I would include a copy or two of this book in an elementary school library as well as a middle school library. It is important to include books featuring girls playing sports. In addition, Breakaway causes the tween/teen reader to reflect on how we treat one another and some of the relational/ peer considerations that are so pertinent to this stage in their lives.
Title: Took: A Ghost Story
ReplyDeleteBy: Mary Downing Hahn
Age recommendation: 9-12, grades 4-8
Audience to whom it will appeal: Anyone who loves a well spun mystery/ghost story.
Strengths of Book: Hahn does a fantastic job of creating real, believable characters. The main character, thirteen year-old Daniel Anderson deals with the sudden move of his family from an affluent life in Connecticut to a rundown farmhouse in the wilderness of West Virginia where danger lurks in the surrounding woods and in stories of Old Auntie by his new schoolmates. The ghost story is told with a folktale feel making it all the more believable. The point of view switches between Daniel and Old Auntie which builds eerie and ominous tones. Then Daniel's younger sister, Erica, starts becoming more withdrawn, talking to her doll, and speaking of a voice she hears. Are the stories at school true? Is there an Old Auntie who takes a little girl every fifty years and her scary resurrected razorback hog, Bloody Bones.
Weaknesses of Book: At some points the mystery is a bit predictable.
Special Considerations: The mysterious nature and magical qualities of Old Auntie may scare some readers.
Verdict: This book is a relatable read for middle schoolers who are fans of spooky stories. Readers will be able to relate to Daniel’s frustration that the adults in his life don’t take him seriously and don’t listen to him. The spookiness and suspenseful nature of the story is not so far over-the-top scary or violent that it is disturbing. I would definitely keep this in the middle school media center.
Book title: See No Color by Shannon Gibney
ReplyDeleteThis book was written for high school girls, but I think it would appeal to upper middle school students as well. More specifically, female sports fans will enjoy the book, but I also think those who aren’t necessarily sports fans will go for it as well.
Strengths – The quality of the writing is good and the storyline is intriguing as it is about a biracial girl, African American and Caucasian, named Alex who was adopted as a baby by a Caucasian family. Her adopted father is a baseball fanatic and has been training her and her brother for years. Once Alex learns that her birth father has been writing her letters that her adoptive parents have kept from her, she begins to try to answer her questions about her birth family and even more importantly, she explores what it means to be African American. This is really the main plotline and the sports element becomes more of a subplot. Gibney handles both parts of the story well.
Alex is a strong character, realistically portrayed and quite likable as well. She enters into a relationship with an African American boy, Reggie, but doesn’t need to be saved by him. She prefers to work things out on her own.
Weaknesses – There may be a misleading notion that this is a sports book, even with the title. However, I do not see that as too much of a problem. There are plenty of sports scenes in the book to entertain the sports enthusiast.
Another possible issue with this book is that even with the suggestion of a sports theme, boys may still perceive this as a “girl’s” book which narrows the audience.
Special considerations - Alex and Reggie engage in sexual activities and there is some cursing as well. But more important, is the inner turmoil Alex is dealing with regarding her identity. She struggles with the fact that she is biracial having grown up in a white world. Meeting Reggie, she discovers how much she doesn’t know about the black perspective. She questions her place in the black community and begins to find herself and how she fits in. This book is certainly more about identity and self-perception than sports.
My verdict – Get this book for your high school library! A book with an athletic biracial female protagonist is just the text to support a multicultural library. It is a must-have for sure!
Game Seven
ReplyDeleteBy: Paul Volponi
This story is about a boy (Julio junior) whose papi (Julio senior) flees Cuba to play professional baseball in the United States, when Junior is 10 years old. He's now 16 and baseball is his life. He'd love to play for the Cuba Nacionales. He's very angry with his father. Believing he's living a life of luxury while he had to quit school to work and his mother is a maid. The opportunity presents itself for Junior to flee Cuba and be with his papi. He's unsure if he should "abandon" his family like his father did...
Audience: Boys grades 6+
Appeals to: Youth, especially boys, interested in baseball. Possibly reluctant readers because the story is so interesting.
Strengths: It's an enjoyable read that keeps the attention of the reader with all of the action taking place throughout the story. The title of the book, sets the big scene in the story. Game seven of the world series. After it's over, will father and son be reunited? The book is full of passion-for the sport of baseball as well as family.
Weaknesses: It was a predictable read. The ending left me
questioning.
Verdict: I think this is a must have for any middle school library. Boys will be drawn to a story like this, filled with sports and action. d