Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children, by Ransom Riggs:
This series was written for teens, but appeals to a very wide audience, from 5th grade up to adults. The "found" artwork provides a sense of authenticity and believability to the plot, jumping from modern times to a past that exists both in and out of the time continuum. Much like Harry Potter, readers will feel the sense of wonder and belonging to the new, magical world of "peculiardom", and will never look at birds the same way. The only weakness I would mention would be that it helps if the reader has some background historical knowledge through WWII, in order to understand the significance of the time period and setting, which can be difficult for audiences younger than 13. Similarly, the amount of violence and terror in both the text and some of the artwork can (and has) cause nightmares if the readers are not ready for it.
Verdict: A "must" for any secondary library; packed with unique story lines, fascinating and memorable characters, and themes of bravery and loyalty.
I have always wanted to read this series but haven't found the time. Thanks for the review. I hope to get to reading this before the movie (directed by Time Burton) comes out on Christmas 2016.
I have also wanted to read this one, and now I see there are two more book to add to the story. The movie will certainly draw more kids to the story for sure. I will be reading this one soon for sure.
I'm in the minority on this one. I started in but had a very hard time with it and didn't end up finishing it. I know, tho, that I've had a TON of students that love it and go on to read the rest of the series, but sadly it didn't work for me.
They are making it into a movie, so that should be interesting!
I just picked this book up from the library. I'm excited to try it! When I was searching for ya mystery books, this title popped up. Would any of you agree with that genre?
Hi Jessica, Yes this qualifies as a mystery. The protagonist is investigating the death of his grandfather. He sees something that he believes is supernatural and/or impossible, so it reads a lot like an X-Files episode.
I have read only the first book in the series. I found the photographs fascinating! Books two and three keep going off the shelves when they are returned in my media center. It is a popular series and one that I want to finish. I would agree, Jessica, it is a mystery but more like a scifi mystery.
Howl’s Moving Castle by Diana Wynne Jones is a fantasy novel, first published in 1986, and adapted for an animated film by the same name in 2004 by the famous Japanese director Hayao Miyazaki. I chose this book because it is my 16-year old goddaughter’s favorite novel. Wynne wrote the novel for young people, and its creative seed was planted by a school boy who asked the author to write a book called, “The Moving Castle.” Jones’ target audience was young adults; however, this thirty-year old novel continues to delight young people as well as adults. Suitable for middle school through adult.
Strengths: Jones creates an intriguing world without lengthy explanation, a world in which it is considered unfortunate to be first born. Her matter-of-fact delivery is “just right.” Her telling captures the imagination and ushers one to that beautiful place-- the willing suspension of disbelief. The writing is also witty and humorous and includes fun chapter titles, such as “Chapter 16: In Which There Is a Great Deal of Witchcraft.”
In this fantastical world, the dashing magician Howl and his celestial partner Calcifer, a fire demon who powers the moving castle, accept and adopt poor runaway Sophie, a hat shop apprentice who was cursed with old age prematurely by the Witch of the Waste. Sophie is resigned to misfortune as she is the eldest child in her family, but the curse of old age causes Sophie to abandon her former life, and she finds refuge in Howl’s castle as his cleaning lady. Inside the supernatural castle walls, Sophie hones her own magic skills as she “talks life” into inanimate objects and finds comfort in her friendships with Calcifer and Michael, Howl’s young apprentice. Sophie’s relationship with Howl is more complicated and a detached and suppressed romance plays throughout the novel that ends most splendidly. The treatment of love, assumptions, and desire is paced and delivered beautifully. Themes of vanity, cowardice, and loyalty prevail.
Special considerations: This book is the first in a series of three about Howl. Next in the trilogy is Castle in the Air, c. 1990, and then there’s House of Many Ways, c. 2008. The Miyazaki film Howl’s Moving Castle, takes a very different plot twist from the book, while maintaining some key elements.
Given the book’s original publication date, it will be off the radar for many adolescents. Help your J.K. Rowling, Robin McKinley, and Neil Gaiman fans discover this fantasy gem. Howl’s Moving Castle is a must-have for your media center collection.
I love this books and the movie. It's one of my favorite. I like the Miyazaki's Howls Moving Castle. What attracted me to it, is his way of interpreting the movement of the characters and the plots twist that is totally different from the books and the way he tell the story. Its so amazingly awesome and different.
Fantastic review! I will definitely keep this series in mind if I am in a secondary school. I enjoy turning kids onto great books that were published "before their time." There are so many great books that students would never discover if they stuck with only newly and recently published works.
“Graceling” by Kristin Cashore is a great YA for teens—both girls and boys—that like high fantasy, quests, and political intrigue mixed with a little romance. It is definitely better for older teens as it includes some sex scenes. Katsa is a teenager who grew up in a kingdom where some are born with a “grace” or special talent. Her grace is killing and her uncle, the king, takes advantage of it. Katsa is strong in body and mind. Her grace controls her at the beginning, but eventually she learns to control it. Once she gets out from under her uncle's control, she makes her own good decisions and discovers her true grace is so much more than she thought. Katsa has good, powerful friendships. And what is most important to her is to be true to herself.
Strengths: Katsa is a strong female character. At first she was afraid of becoming romantically involved because she thought it would take away a part of her. She eventually discovers that she can be independent and still love another completely. The romantic/sexual tension builds throughout the first half of the book and when the two characters finally discover and reveal their feelings for each other, it is so satisfying. Several of the best-written scenes I have read in YA. I could not put it down.
All of Cashore’s characters are well written, interesting, and believable. Her world building is detailed but not too flowery and very well thought out.
Weaknesses: I enjoyed this book so much that I find it impossible to find any weaknesses. In other personal reviews (mostly on GoodReads.com) some have complained about it’s “feminist agenda.” I didn’t see it that way at all though.
The best part about this book is that even though there are two companion novels, it actually ends in a way that leaves you happy and satisfied rather than hanging and waiting for a sequel.
Verdict: A must have for a high school collection for fans of both fantasy and romance. (The companion novels “Fire” and “Bitterblue” are also excellent!)
I do need to read this book yet!!! It's been out for a long while and I wish it would resurge! I know that the reviews have always been very very positive for it mainly because of that strong female lead.
I like that it ends in a satisfactory way so if you don't read the other books you at least feel like you got the whole story and are ok.
Eragon (Inheritance Series) by Christopher Paolini. (Fantasy)
This book is written for grade 5 to grade 9. The book might appeal to readers that are captivated by fantasy of magic and dragon. The strength of book is the descriptions of the characters and the surrounding scenery and area giving the readers the feeling of being at the same place with the characters. The weakness of the book is the plots situation that doesn’t make any sense at all for an example learning to read in less than one week. The distances that are covered either randomly long or sometime extremely short. It seems the character of the books seems familiar to other books like the Dwarfs, Elves and Urgals. I like that the book put a map to see the journey of the characters are taking. The cover of the books has a great illustration of the dragon from the book. The cover could have been more in depth with the major character and be more colorful than just one color.
Verdict: The inheritance series is a must for a library especially for students who love fantasy. The empathetic characters and interesting plot twist will appeal to lord of the rings trilogy readers.
Agreed! It's a little more simplistic than LOTR, so it is likely a good introduction to classic fantasy characters, styles and settings before tackling the "big dogs" like Hobbit and LOTR.
The series is perfect for all media centers serving grades 4-12. Advanced younger readers will enjoy it as well as older teens who may be a few grades behind in their skills. It is the type of book that won't be embarrassing at the check out desk for a high school student who is just getting comfortable with longer books.
This novel was unlike anything I've read before. It is part realistic fiction, part spirituality narrative, part fantasy, part romance, the list goes on. Sierra is an admirable, witty heroine. She talks a mile a minute, paints stunning murals in the city late into the night and has a family secret that she can't quite figure out. For some mysterious reason, her elderly abuelo (grandfather) who hasn't spoken in months starts muttering "lo siento" (I'm sorry) and Sierra wants to know why. Her adventure takes her into a “thrilling collision of artistry and spirituality” (47) that shows young women can be just as powerful as men in any realm. I found myself admiring Sierra for her courage and laughing as she and her friends dealt with every day teenager angst alongside issues of life and death (think Hunger Games or Divergent with a spiritual twist). VERDICT: I think this magical book would make a great addition to any middle or high school media center. It has the power to grab the unsuspecting reader and hold on for the ride, meanwhile exposing him or her to issues worth discussing: race, identity, family, culture, art, heritage, and the power of art to transform relationships.
That sounds like a good read. I am curious about the Spanish in the book. Is there much Spanish in the book, and is there also a glossary for those unfamiliar with the language? Do you think this would appeal to Hispanic teens especially or is it the appeal broad?
Jenny- As the other reader of this book for the class, I would have to say that it may appeal to some Hispanic teens maybe more than the overall school population as a whole because they may see some "mirrors" of themselves, with regard to the food references, culture, dance, and some Spanish. The Spanish is an appropriate amount, meaning that non-Spanish speakers would not get lost in their reading due to the language. I think "Ms. Rose" and I will have an interesting discussion during class, though I believe we had a different overall opinion of the book. To me, the last 1/4 of the book played out like a bad Scooby Doo episode. I just wanted it to END already. So, now I need to investigate if that has more to do with my own distaste for the genre as a whole, or if it goes beyond that. Still pondering....
https://images.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwpmedia.arts.nationalpost.com%2F2014%2F02%2Fthe-martian-by-andy-weir.jpg&f=1 The Martian by Andy Weir
The book is written for Middle/High School students. This book will also appeal to adults.
The strengths of this book are the story is told in such a way that a reader can visualize Mark Watney’s thought processes. Mark uses his engineering skills along with a keen wit and figures out how to grow enough food to survive until the next mission to Mars arrives. He also figures out how to get to the place on Mars where the next Mission is going to arrive, as the location is many kilometers from his current location. In other words, Mark has a lot of problems to solve.
Another strength is that the book is based on real science. The author, Andy Weir began working as a programmer at the age of 15 and is currently working as a software programmer. His hobbies are relativistic physics, orbital mechanics, and the history of manned spaceflight.
A weakness of the book is that it is very technically detailed in its descriptions. If a reader does not have a keen interest in reading a lot of technical details, you might find it difficult to get through. Also, the “problem solving aspect” of the book I thought was a little tiring. You could easily predict that there was going to be another problem to solve.
A curriculum link could be created whereby you can make a chart of all the obstacles Mark had to overcome. This chart could also be used in a book trailer to spark interest in the book. Also, overcoming obstacles could be a discussion point for overcoming obstacles in real life.
Verdict: A detailed and science based book that appeals to readers interested in science and quality writing. I would definitely include this book in my collection.
Nuts...I tried to put a photo of the book in my blog, however it did not work. I like to see a photo of the books people are talking about as it helps me remember the book.
This book has strong YA crossover appeal, but was written for adults and marketed to them. I do agree that it's got some great examples of problem solving and would appeal to kids with an interest in space travel, engineering, and science. I loved the book, but then I'm a big sci-fi nerd.
I've been thinking of picking this one up, though not in my typical area of interest. I have to say that when my husband asked if I wanted to see the movie, I was not overly excited about it (though any movie can be redeemed by the presence of Matt Damon... but I digress.) I ended up REALLY liking the movie.. maybe not loving. There is enough of a good story to keep interest even for those who may not gravitate to the genre/subject. I wonder if you would include it in both middle and high school library?
Mark Watney is an amusing and witty character. Both my son (18) and I laughed out loud at his comments and antics throughout this book. It provided an immensely enjoyable read for both of us.
To answer Laura's question about including it in both middle and high school, I vote absolutely.
I think this would be an excellent teacher read aloud story for grades 4 and 5 at our STEM magnet. The story is not complex and while the technical information may go over the heads of younger readers, the teacher can help them put all the pieces together while highlighting the problem solving aspect of the adventure.
Laura, I think this book could be in both a middle and high school Library. It just depends on the reader and what level they are at. Some middle school students are reading at a high school level, therefore I would include it in a middle school library.
The main character Mark Watney is amusing, entertaining, and enduring to readers, but the language takes away from the story for middle schoolers. For this reason, I think this book is better suited for the high school media center due to the language.
The beginning of a new fantasy series, "Six of Crows" follows Kaz Brekker - con artist, thief, ambitious gang leader - and his unlikely band of rogues as they take on an impossible mission. They must break into the impenetrable stronghold of Fjerda and save a chemist before he reveals the secret of a dangerous drug. If they do not succeed, rival countries will use the drug to abuse the powers of the magical Grisha and control the world.
This book has been much lauded, it's easy to see why. The stage is set with anti-heros, each driven with inner revenge, but each unique and relatable. There are no princes or princesses to be found on the streets of Ketterdam. Each character comes with secret strengths, gaping flaws, horrid pasts and hidden desires, and though none of them are honorable, they capture you with their stories as they embark on a mission they can't hope to return from.
The new series works in the same world as Barduro's previous "Grisha" series, but it operates independently in that world. Whether you liked, hated, or never heard of her other works (I fall in the 3rd category), this book has something for everyone.
Some may find the beginning of the book slow, as time is taken to introduce (or re-introduce) the world and it's characters. You won't know you're hooked until you try to put it down.
This book has a few dark themes such as indenture and slavery, prostitution, drugs, and a bit of a violent streak. It is often recommended for grades 8+. If any of our students enjoy fantasy and adventure, this is one to include on the shelf, especially in high school. In a middle school, consider your collection and audience - if your readers are drawn to mature, engaging plots, then I'd put this on your shelf too - I know I would have picked it up!
Verdict: Anti-heroes are the new princes! The strong characters and mysterious plot will keep this book off your shelves - but only if you put it there first!
I'm very involved in the young adult book blogging community and this book has a HUGE following. Lots and lots of positive reviews on it. A few that aren't thrilled with it, but over-all people seem to like it.
I'm curious about and really should step out of my comfort zone and read it. I didn't read her other series for the same reason - it's just not something I'd typically pick up. But because I've heard good things about, and I'd like to see if it's something I'd shelve I really should read it. From what you say about it, and knowing the readers at the middle school I was at, it is one they'd all really be drawn to.
Thanks for picking it for this class and sharing your thoughts.
Ellie - This was one of the books I requested but STILL haven't received it. I am intrigued by this one and plan to read it soon. Thank you for acknowledging the slow start. Without knowing that, I might have given up. Good thing to tell the future readers of this book.
Good to know about the slow start. It's helpful if you can tell students that but also tell them to hang in there. Sounds like a great new trend of anti-heroes!
a. Audience for whom the book is written. Middle school/high school students.
b. Audience for whom the book will appeal. Anyone who likes Hunger Games and/or Divergent as this book is a cross between the two. It might appeal more to younger teens or those who are firmly set in the genre.
c. Strengths This is a compelling story for teens and with plenty of action it will draw students in for sure especially those who like the genre. There is also a strong female protagonist who is smart and capable. The descriptions of the setting were interesting and the author gives plenty of background on the history of the country and what happened to it.
d. Weaknesses It is a predictable story that seems to have too much in common with books that have come before it like Hunger Games and Divergent.
e. Special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.) As with typical dystopian novels, the presence of an oppressive government that doesn’t seem to care about its citizens is the main focus of this text. In this case, the protagonist has no idea how oppressive the government is until she’s selected for testing and starts to see more of the world she’s been cut off from.
This is another text in which the characters are encouraged to fight each other in order to win, so there are some violent scenes throughout. There is also violence directly from government officials during the testing period as characters are punished for getting wrong answers.
f. Your verdict (with details): The Testing would be a good addition to any library collection as it will draw some students in and provide them with a strong female protagonist and an action-packed story line; however, I would not recommend buying too many copies of this predictable book.
Thanks for the tip. I'd agree 2 or 3 copies per book is probably enough. It hasn't been flying off the shelves like Cinder, The Selection, Hunger Games, Divergent or Maze Runner... but it might just get there if they make a movie out of it! I'd rather see Cinder as a movie first.
I would agree with that. Cinder would make a fun movie to see. I thought that was a great read. On another note, I did have some kids want to read The Testing as I brought it back to school and did a book talk on it. It is now in high demand in my classroom.
Thanks for your review on this one. It's been around for awhile and when I shared it with my students not many picked it up. So I completely agree with your thoughts on not carrying too many copies if any.
I envision this book appealing STEM high school students or students in a STEM course within a high school. Andy Weir's technical writing is fascinating and jam packed with details. Andy Weir was first hired as a programmer for a national laboratory at age fifteen. It mentions in the biography at the back of the book that he is a lifelong space nerd and enjoys hobbies such as relativistic physics, orbital mechanics, and the history of manned flight. The Martian was his first novel. The book was written for an upper middle-high school audience.
Strengths: Andy Weir does a great job of explaining all the technical, mechanical and/or biological processes throughout the book. The book moves at a fast pace which makes it a fast interesting read. Mark Watney is a likable character because he is clever, witty, and has a sense of humor so you will find yourself rooting for him throughout the book.
Weaknesses: There is predictability throughout the story. There is a catastrophic event, a moment of suspense, and then Mark Watney comes up with a clever solution and diverts the emergency.
This book is written technically rich and for students who are not mathematical or scientifically inclined I would worry that they would not make it past the first couple pages.
Verdict: The language is vulgar at times and there is some sexual content. I believe that this would be a good addition to any high school or upper middle school library particularly for students interested in science, math, and/or engineering
Yes, the story is predictable however it demonstrates that no matter how many obstacles a person encounters, there is a possible solution. This is what I really liked about this book. I don't think you really need to be mathematical or scientifically minded to read the book. I think it is possible to understand what is happening without being a techie.
This story was strange. It kept my interest, but it was very hard for me to follow. I kept waiting for something more to happen. There is probably an underlying theme, but I have no idea what it is-I'm guessing I'm not smart enough! I can't figure out who would actually like this story. To sum it up, the main character is a spirit that moves to a different host body every day. One day, "it" falls in love with a teenage girl. They develop a relationship. The end. Audience written for: Gr.8+
Audience appeals: ?
Strengths: The story is interesting enough to keep me reading. The characters live life in a relatable way to the reader, with the exception of "A" whom moves from body to body every day. Meaning, they attend school, parties, etc. The author uses language that the audience can follow.
Weaknesses: Personally, I couldn't connect with the story or any of the characters. I kept waiting for something big to happen to help me understand what was going on.
Final Verdict: The story was just ok for me. I can't seem to find a way that readers would connect with it. I don't see a purpose to reading it.
I can see how some may find it difficult to connect with the premise of this story. Levithan asks the reader to consider the notion that a being can exist only in a form of consciousness manifesting themselves to humans only when they are a parasite on another human being. A has no body, no gender, no sexuality. A wakes up in a different stranger’s body every morning and has to live their life for a day, until A is whisked away at midnight only to repeat the process again tomorrow. A tries not to interfere too much in people’s lives, until he meets Rhiannon, falls in love, and starts to break the rules one by one and as he does so, the reader is faced with the question, What makes each of us an individual - what makes me, "me"?
Audience for whom written: Ages 14-18
Audience for whom appeals: Ages 14-18 who like to contemplate life’s big questions. I think it appeals equally to boys and girls. The asexual nature of A may appeal to LGBTQ students.
Strengths: • Although each ‘host’ is sixteen years old, each has a very different story to tell. The number of “types” that are addressed by the various bodies that A inhabits allows the students to consider how they view/judge those types – obese, female, male, rich, poor,
Weaknesses: • For those who are not fans of the fantasy genre, this really asks you to accept the ability to exist only as a consciousness – without any substance beyond a parasitic existence.
Special Considerations: • The ending leaves many unanswered questions. Although Every Day is, on the surface, a simple idea, it throws up a lot of complicated questions. What defines who you are? Is gender a silly concept? What about sexuality? Is A doing something morally wrong? Is it better to experience many different things, or see a few the whole way through? • A takes very good care of the bodies he inhabits – following the concept of time travelers – don’t make changes or alter the life of the person. A does interfere, however, to help one girl who is contemplating suicide. • This book has been used successfully as an all school read for incoming college freshmen allowing the student body to discuss the deeper issues mentioned above.
Verdict: I would include this in my high school library and probably a middle school library depending on your student demographics.
I love a book that gets kids to think deeply! I have wanted to read this one because I thought the premise was so unique and I like David Levithan. Thanks for your review!
This book was written for and will definitely appeal to middle and high school students, especially those who like supernatural characters like werewolves.
c. Strengths
The female protagonist, Grace, leads this story about a girl who was attacked by a pack of werewolves early in her life and was saved by one. This ignites her love of wolves and feels drawn to them over the years, not realizing that they are actually werewolves. She later meets the werewolf who saved her long ago in his human form and they fall in love. As a character, Grace is strong and steadfast in her love of the animals and her desire to protect her new love. While this storyline is obviously not plausible, it is an interesting twist to the typical teenage romance, at least for those who like this subgenre. Again, outside the werewolf concept, the teens and their choices, their behavior is believable as they run around trying to find a new werewolf gone rogue. Finally, the writing is good and descriptive in both the natural setting and of the teens’ interactions with the other characters. In fact, the writing is a much higher quality than other popular supernatural fantasy books, such as Twilight, that have been more popular.
d. Weaknesses Shiver is somewhat predictable, especially once one has already read the countless other werewolf and vampire books available. I could guess what was coming before it came and I would suspect or even expect the well-read teen would too. The unfortunate thing about this is that Shiver is one of many books in this subgenre and it can get overlooked.
e. Special considerations The reader needs to be open to this concept of werewolves and accept the story as it is, a fantasy. The idea of love across “species” is not new at all, but this story hinges on it and the predictable nature of how this story progresses. There are suggestions of teen sex, but nothing graphic is described. However, there is a lot of violence as werewolves are attacking people or showing victims after they have been attacked. Often YA literature includes adult figure who are weak or nonexistent and in this case, Grace’s parents are present very little in the story and are often portrayed as a secondary set of antagonists. It is definitely teens and werewolves against the world in this story.
f. Your verdict (with details): The whole Shiver trilogy will be a good addition to your library as, if nothing else, it will give teens who are into this genre another set of books to keep them going.
oh my goodness, i loved, loved this book! i couldn't put it down and immediately started the sequel (which i didn't like as much-i'm about to start the last one) while the story is fantasy, there were still realistic and relatable parts. i think teenage girls can definitely connect to grace-heck, i could, thinking back to meeting my first love. great review michelle.
I loved these books too. Great for those teens that have already read "Twilight" and other supernatural series. And this series can be a gateway into other fantastic books by Maggie Stiefvater including "The Scorpio Races" (my favorite!), "Lament" and "Ballad" (fairies), and the Raven Boys series.
I agree with Michelle that the book is predictable for an adult reader and I have to wonder if a teen may find comfort in that. They can have so much unpredictability in their social circles that a book like this, with a simple plot trajectory, offers a safe place to hang out for a while.
A strength for this book stems from the author's link to music, art and writing. Stiefvater is herself a songwriter and the lyrics she includes are pretty good (in the audio book they are read lyrically and it adds a nice touch to the story). I think you could entice some reluctant readers to the series through the musical aspects of the book.
I was immediately curious about the chapter titles and the fact that they include the temperature. I found myself checking these and referring back to them as the mystery of the wolves unfolded. It would be interesting to draw students into the series by asking them to predict when the temperature will drop below a certain point - a media center contest of sorts.
Students near Duluth will relate to the location and may enjoy trying to place Mercy Falls.
Like Jessica, I was intrigued enough with the story to immediately read the second book, Linger. I will read the 3rd book in hopes that the story redeems itself. I found the boy obsession in the 2nd book over the top but now I have to find out what happens. I believe teens will have the same reaction and that will keep them reading - always a good thing!
Verdict: I would definitely include the series in a high school collection and focus on some of the unique aspects of music and the Minnesota setting to draw readers attention to the series.
By far...my favorite book from this class! I simply cannot wait to read the rest of the trilogy. Even though I did find the plot to be predictable, I found that comforting. It was a good, clean read. Captured my interest immediately and held it the entire time. Glad you enjoyed it, too!
Strengths: Set in the year 2035, the protagonist, Dahlia (16), is learning to survive in a world that is controlled by 8 major corporations known as the C-8. Dahlia has a strong sense of who she is and how she relates with a world that is both controlled and segregated by C-8 until she is sought out by Michael. Michael, former band singer and financially rich, is putting together a group of 7 teens to take on the C-8 corporation. Each member has a certain strength of their own.
Weaknesses: Although the book is set in the years 2035, very little is explained to detail. The setting is very vague. The same could be said of the characters, too. At the beginning, Dahlia is presented with information on each character and what he/she brings to the table. I wish more of this would have played out throughout the story. The entire plot seems to be a mile wide and only centimeters deep. I found it very difficult to connect with any of the characters or to see how they were to work together. This is also true of the understanding of C-8 and their part in the story. At no time does Dahlia or her group members come in contact with this world dominating organization.
Special Considerations: I would rate this book for the High School audience only because it is a difficult storyline to follow.
Verdict: 2 stars - I would not recommend this book for a library collection. The storyline was all over the place and never quite came together. The characters are not well developed and I don't quite understand where it falls within the Sci-Fi category.
Talley I hadn't heard of this one by WDM. Sorry to hear it wasn't that good since so many of his books are high quality. I too have a hard time with a book when I cannot connect to the characters. Thanks for reading and sharing.
Talley I hadn't heard of this one by WDM. Sorry to hear it wasn't that good since so many of his books are high quality. I too have a hard time with a book when I cannot connect to the characters. Thanks for reading and sharing.
Jill - Everything I read about WDM, online, shared the same viewpoints as you. Sounds like he was a great author and so many of his books were of high interest. This one was a dud. I think it was because he tried to make so many "connections" with a variety of issues and didn't give them the attention or time needed. If I am remembering correctly, I believe this was one of his last books before passing away. I'll have to check in on that!
Grades 5 and up-- Rooted in folklore with hints of mystery, magical realism and young love, The Girl Who Could Silence the Wind by Meg Medina tells the story of a small town that believes that one of their own has the power to change their futures, but for her, the pressure has become too much and she has to make a decision to
Intended audience: According to Medina’s site, she aimed to write a telenovela style story for kids of all ages. I would say more specifically upper elementary students, boys and girls, Spanish speakers.
Audience to whom it may appeal: I think that the novel may appeal to kids and adults alike, those who are interested in a coming of age tale with a few twists and turns. It may also appeal to those interested in learning about magical realism and perhaps those interested in studying the Spanish language.
Strengths: The time and place of the tale is obscure enough that it could be anywhere at anytime which lends it to a unique experience for each and every reader. Its timeless themes of family, perseverance and love make for a relatable read for all types of readers.
Weaknesses: While the obscurity of the setting may be enjoyable for readers with strong imaginative skills, some might find the lack of descriptive language hard to picture and follow. There is a sprinkling of Spanish phrases throughout the novel that might discourage readers with no prior knowledge of the language or cultural practices.
VERDICT: An allegory for finding the balance between family and following your heart, this novel would be an excellent addition to an elementary or middle school library for students seeking a story with soul.
I envision this book appealing to middle school students seeking an adventure series. The characters are realistic and relatable yet the setting is mysterious and imaginative.
Strengths: The male protagonist, Thomas, is a likable character because he is quick-witted, kind-hearted and has a sense of humor. You will sympathize and find yourself cheering him on throughout the book. The adventure and fast pace of this novel makes it a quick read. The ending definitely leaves you longing for answers and craving the next book in the series to see what’s going to happen next.
Weaknesses: The similarities between The Hunger Games and The Maze Runner are prominent. The setting in both series is a post-apocalyptic world with a young teenage hero standing up to fight for their life against the rulers.
Verdict: I believe that this would be a good addition to any middle school library particularly for students interested in dystopian novels. For students who were intrigued by The Hunger Games and Divergent series this would be another series that would capture their attention. There is violence throughout the book with certain parts a bit more goory than others. I would be sure to use that as a disclaimer when recommending.
This is another very popular series in my media center. When Scorch Trials was released as a movie, there was a lot of hype in the middle school. I personally enjoyed the first book and found the descriptions of the Grievers to be creepy enough to stick with you even after closing the cover.
Kino No Tabi: Book One of the Beautiful World by Keiichi Sigsawa Genre: Fantasy Fiction Pages: 208 Published: TokyoPop in 2016
The story is based around a girl named Kino and her talking motorcycle Hermes. She rides the motorcycle from town to town, only staying in each place for exactly three days. In this volume, Kino comes across a democratic ghost town, a scientifically advanced town of empathy, and a town where you are only granted entrance after winning a fight to the death.
Audience: This book will capture the interest of anime and manga fans, especially since it’s been made into an animated TV series. It could be read from sixth grade to twelfth grade.
Strengths: The towns and short stories present very strong, parallel metaphors to the world today. The reader learns a new moral lesson in each town that Kino visits. These lessons can easily be understood by younger students because they are portrayed on a smaller, more tangible, scale. This makes for a great starting point in discussions. Also, there is a bit of mystery shrouding each village, so the reader is always wondering what happens next.
Weaknesses: The book is a collection of five to six short stories of Kino’s experiences in various towns. The stories are not connected and do not directly build off of each other. There are also parts of the plot that are left unexplained and are most likely retouched further along in the series. This may leave the reader feeling that the story is very disjointed.
Special Considerations: There are a few violent scenes throughout the book. In the opening town, a man is stabbed to death protecting a girl from her parent, who are trying to kill her. There is a man who has ordered everyone in his village executed. And in the final town, people are killing each other in order to gain entrance into a town. Kino is also very skilled with a gun and uses it throughout the book to protect herself.
Verdict: This book would be a great addition to a middle or high school media center. Sigsawa skillfully twists fantasy and realistic ideas to create a book that causes you to think deeper about the humanity of humanity.
City of Ember by Jeanne Duprau Age Level: 8-12 Grades: 3-7
The City of Ember is a city that is completely lit by lightbulbs. There are no sun, moon, or stars. The city is run by a large generator that is on its last legs. The two main characters, Lina Mayfleet and Doon Harrow try to discover ways to save the city and also escape successfully. Little do they know that the original founders of Ember had eventual escape plans drawn out for future Ember citizens. Those lost plans were discovered by Lina not in there original form.
Strengths: Duprau does an excellent job of mixing a science-fiction story with andventure and intrigue. You find yourself cheering on Lina and Doon to solve the mysterious plans to exit Ember. Duprau leaves you enough clues to try to solve the riddle on your own, but not enough to actually solve it.
Weakness: If you do not like cliff hangers, you will be disappointed in the end. You must read the first chapter of next book, "People of Sparks," to see what happens. Others may find this a strength of the book. The movie is dreadful. Don't ever see it. I only imagine that Jeanne Duprau gave up her creative rights on the move.
Verdict: Any reader will enjoy this book. High schoolers would also enjoy this book! It's one of my favorite reads! Even readers that do not enjoy the science fiction genre will enjoy this book.
Loved this book, and yes kids like it too. It's a good one to give to them after they've made their way through some of the other dystopia OR if they are younger and maybe not ready for The Hunger Games. It's tamer. Have you read the others in the series? I wasn't as impressed by them - especially the prequel. I also found that kids didn't like them as much. From a media specialist perspective I'd have them in the media center (the sequels), but I wouldn't have very many copies.
Audience to whom it will appeal: Wide range of science fiction, fantasy, fairy tale readers. Predominantly appeals to female readers. Readers who’ve enjoyed the Lunar Chronicles Series.
Strengths of Book: Meyer takes the reader to another world, another planet in Luna a moon colony where magic, “glamour,” love, deceit, death, and heartache control the characters. Fairest: Levana’s Story is a well-crafted spin on the evil queen from the fairytale Snow White. Readers are not sure if they should cheer on Levana in her misguided quest for acceptance, love, and power; or if they should dislike her for her evil, unforgiving, and manipulative nature.
Weaknesses of Book: At times the plot drags and the dynamics between the main character Levana and her husband, Evret are strained and boring. The love story turns more to a melodrama causing Levana to lose some of her edge. Special Considerations: The subject matter does contain some cautionary aspects such as brutality, murder, sex (although not explicit), and mutilation.
Verdict: Overall this book is a creative look at familiar fairy tales and the ultimate struggle between good and evil. Through Levana’s life, readers are able to dive into a world that is rooted in falsehoods where people hide behind “glamours” and find empathy with truly good characters. I would place this book in the middle school media center as it is a vital part of the Lunar Chronicles and completes the series.
Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children, by Ransom Riggs:
ReplyDeleteThis series was written for teens, but appeals to a very wide audience, from 5th grade up to adults. The "found" artwork provides a sense of authenticity and believability to the plot, jumping from modern times to a past that exists both in and out of the time continuum. Much like Harry Potter, readers will feel the sense of wonder and belonging to the new, magical world of "peculiardom", and will never look at birds the same way. The only weakness I would mention would be that it helps if the reader has some background historical knowledge through WWII, in order to understand the significance of the time period and setting, which can be difficult for audiences younger than 13. Similarly, the amount of violence and terror in both the text and some of the artwork can (and has) cause nightmares if the readers are not ready for it.
Verdict: A "must" for any secondary library; packed with unique story lines, fascinating and memorable characters, and themes of bravery and loyalty.
I have always wanted to read this series but haven't found the time. Thanks for the review. I hope to get to reading this before the movie (directed by Time Burton) comes out on Christmas 2016.
DeleteI have also wanted to read this one, and now I see there are two more book to add to the story. The movie will certainly draw more kids to the story for sure. I will be reading this one soon for sure.
DeleteI'm in the minority on this one. I started in but had a very hard time with it and didn't end up finishing it. I know, tho, that I've had a TON of students that love it and go on to read the rest of the series, but sadly it didn't work for me.
DeleteThey are making it into a movie, so that should be interesting!
I just picked this book up from the library. I'm excited to try it! When I was searching for ya mystery books, this title popped up. Would any of you agree with that genre?
DeleteHi Jessica, Yes this qualifies as a mystery. The protagonist is investigating the death of his grandfather. He sees something that he believes is supernatural and/or impossible, so it reads a lot like an X-Files episode.
DeleteI have read only the first book in the series. I found the photographs fascinating! Books two and three keep going off the shelves when they are returned in my media center. It is a popular series and one that I want to finish. I would agree, Jessica, it is a mystery but more like a scifi mystery.
DeleteHowl’s Moving Castle by Diana Wynne Jones is a fantasy novel, first published in 1986, and adapted for an animated film by the same name in 2004 by the famous Japanese director Hayao Miyazaki. I chose this book because it is my 16-year old goddaughter’s favorite novel. Wynne wrote the novel for young people, and its creative seed was planted by a school boy who asked the author to write a book called, “The Moving Castle.” Jones’ target audience was young adults; however, this thirty-year old novel continues to delight young people as well as adults. Suitable for middle school through adult.
ReplyDeleteStrengths: Jones creates an intriguing world without lengthy explanation, a world in which it is considered unfortunate to be first born. Her matter-of-fact delivery is “just right.” Her telling captures the imagination and ushers one to that beautiful place-- the willing suspension of disbelief. The writing is also witty and humorous and includes fun chapter titles, such as “Chapter 16: In Which There Is a Great Deal of Witchcraft.”
In this fantastical world, the dashing magician Howl and his celestial partner Calcifer, a fire demon who powers the moving castle, accept and adopt poor runaway Sophie, a hat shop apprentice who was cursed with old age prematurely by the Witch of the Waste. Sophie is resigned to misfortune as she is the eldest child in her family, but the curse of old age causes Sophie to abandon her former life, and she finds refuge in Howl’s castle as his cleaning lady. Inside the supernatural castle walls, Sophie hones her own magic skills as she “talks life” into inanimate objects and finds comfort in her friendships with Calcifer and Michael, Howl’s young apprentice. Sophie’s relationship with Howl is more complicated and a detached and suppressed romance plays throughout the novel that ends most splendidly. The treatment of love, assumptions, and desire is paced and delivered beautifully. Themes of vanity, cowardice, and loyalty prevail.
Weaknesses: Some readers may be confused by the blurring of time periods in the novel. Howl was born in the 20th century, has relatives who drive cars in contemporary Wales; he played rugby. And yet, he inhabits an 18th or 19th century world in which there are no cars and women wear hats adorned with ribbons, silk flowers, and waxed fruit. Some readers may not be able to accept this alternative dimension into the Land of Ingary, “where such things as seven-league boots and cloaks of invisibility really exist” (p. 1). In addition, the dénouement at the end of the novel may be too abrupt for some readers’ liking.
Special considerations: This book is the first in a series of three about Howl. Next in the trilogy is Castle in the Air, c. 1990, and then there’s House of Many Ways, c. 2008. The Miyazaki film Howl’s Moving Castle, takes a very different plot twist from the book, while maintaining some key elements.
Given the book’s original publication date, it will be off the radar for many adolescents. Help your J.K. Rowling, Robin McKinley, and Neil Gaiman fans discover this fantasy gem. Howl’s Moving Castle is a must-have for your media center collection.
I love this books and the movie. It's one of my favorite. I like the Miyazaki's Howls Moving Castle. What attracted me to it, is his way of interpreting the movement of the characters and the plots twist that is totally different from the books and the way he tell the story. Its so amazingly awesome and different.
DeleteFantastic review! I will definitely keep this series in mind if I am in a secondary school. I enjoy turning kids onto great books that were published "before their time." There are so many great books that students would never discover if they stuck with only newly and recently published works.
Delete"Graceling" by Kristin Cashore
ReplyDelete“Graceling” by Kristin Cashore is a great YA for teens—both girls and boys—that like high fantasy, quests, and political intrigue mixed with a little romance. It is definitely better for older teens as it includes some sex scenes. Katsa is a teenager who grew up in a kingdom where some are born with a “grace” or special talent. Her grace is killing and her uncle, the king, takes advantage of it. Katsa is strong in body and mind. Her grace controls her at the beginning, but eventually she learns to control it. Once she gets out from under her uncle's control, she makes her own good decisions and discovers her true grace is so much more than she thought. Katsa has good, powerful friendships. And what is most important to her is to be true to herself.
Strengths:
Katsa is a strong female character. At first she was afraid of becoming romantically involved because she thought it would take away a part of her. She eventually discovers that she can be independent and still love another completely. The romantic/sexual tension builds throughout the first half of the book and when the two characters finally discover and reveal their feelings for each other, it is so satisfying. Several of the best-written scenes I have read in YA. I could not put it down.
All of Cashore’s characters are well written, interesting, and believable. Her world building is detailed but not too flowery and very well thought out.
Weaknesses:
I enjoyed this book so much that I find it impossible to find any weaknesses. In other personal reviews (mostly on GoodReads.com) some have complained about it’s “feminist agenda.” I didn’t see it that way at all though.
The best part about this book is that even though there are two companion novels, it actually ends in a way that leaves you happy and satisfied rather than hanging and waiting for a sequel.
Verdict: A must have for a high school collection for fans of both fantasy and romance. (The companion novels “Fire” and “Bitterblue” are also excellent!)
I do need to read this book yet!!! It's been out for a long while and I wish it would resurge! I know that the reviews have always been very very positive for it mainly because of that strong female lead.
DeleteI like that it ends in a satisfactory way so if you don't read the other books you at least feel like you got the whole story and are ok.
Eragon (Inheritance Series) by Christopher Paolini. (Fantasy)
ReplyDeleteThis book is written for grade 5 to grade 9. The book might appeal to readers that are captivated by fantasy of magic and dragon. The strength of book is the descriptions of the characters and the surrounding scenery and area giving the readers the feeling of being at the same place with the characters. The weakness of the book is the plots situation that doesn’t make any sense at all for an example learning to read in less than one week. The distances that are covered either randomly long or sometime extremely short. It seems the character of the books seems familiar to other books like the Dwarfs, Elves and Urgals. I like that the book put a map to see the journey of the characters are taking. The cover of the books has a great illustration of the dragon from the book. The cover could have been more in depth with the major character and be more colorful than just one color.
Verdict: The inheritance series is a must for a library especially for students who love fantasy. The empathetic characters and interesting plot twist will appeal to lord of the rings trilogy readers.
leena
Agreed! It's a little more simplistic than LOTR, so it is likely a good introduction to classic fantasy characters, styles and settings before tackling the "big dogs" like Hobbit and LOTR.
DeleteThe series is perfect for all media centers serving grades 4-12. Advanced younger readers will enjoy it as well as older teens who may be a few grades behind in their skills. It is the type of book that won't be embarrassing at the check out desk for a high school student who is just getting comfortable with longer books.
DeleteThis series is popular in my media center. I agree with your assessment that the prose is wordy and familiar to the Lord of the Rings.
DeleteShadowshaper by Daniel Jose Older
ReplyDeleteGrades 6 and up--
This novel was unlike anything I've read before. It is part realistic fiction, part spirituality narrative, part fantasy, part romance, the list goes on.
Sierra is an admirable, witty heroine. She talks a mile a minute, paints stunning murals in the city late into the night and has a family secret that she can't quite figure out. For some mysterious reason, her elderly abuelo (grandfather) who hasn't spoken in months starts muttering "lo siento" (I'm sorry) and Sierra wants to know why. Her adventure takes her into a “thrilling collision of artistry and spirituality” (47) that shows young women can be just as powerful as men in any realm. I found myself admiring Sierra for her courage and laughing as she and her friends dealt with every day teenager angst alongside issues of life and death (think Hunger Games or Divergent with a spiritual twist). VERDICT: I think this magical book would make a great addition to any middle or high school media center. It has the power to grab the unsuspecting reader and hold on for the ride, meanwhile exposing him or her to issues worth discussing: race, identity, family, culture, art, heritage, and the power of art to transform relationships.
That sounds like a good read. I am curious about the Spanish in the book. Is there much Spanish in the book, and is there also a glossary for those unfamiliar with the language? Do you think this would appeal to Hispanic teens especially or is it the appeal broad?
DeleteJenny-
DeleteAs the other reader of this book for the class, I would have to say that it may appeal to some Hispanic teens maybe more than the overall school population as a whole because they may see some "mirrors" of themselves, with regard to the food references, culture, dance, and some Spanish. The Spanish is an appropriate amount, meaning that non-Spanish speakers would not get lost in their reading due to the language. I think "Ms. Rose" and I will have an interesting discussion during class, though I believe we had a different overall opinion of the book. To me, the last 1/4 of the book played out like a bad Scooby Doo episode. I just wanted it to END already. So, now I need to investigate if that has more to do with my own distaste for the genre as a whole, or if it goes beyond that. Still pondering....
https://images.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwpmedia.arts.nationalpost.com%2F2014%2F02%2Fthe-martian-by-andy-weir.jpg&f=1
ReplyDeleteThe Martian by Andy Weir
The book is written for Middle/High School students. This book will also appeal to adults.
The strengths of this book are the story is told in such a way that a reader can visualize Mark Watney’s thought processes. Mark uses his engineering skills along with a keen wit and figures out how to grow enough food to survive until the next mission to Mars arrives. He also figures out how to get to the place on Mars where the next Mission is going to arrive, as the location is many kilometers from his current location. In other words, Mark has a lot of problems to solve.
Another strength is that the book is based on real science. The author, Andy Weir began working as a programmer at the age of 15 and is currently working as a software programmer. His hobbies are relativistic physics, orbital mechanics, and the history of manned spaceflight.
A weakness of the book is that it is very technically detailed in its descriptions. If a reader does not have a keen interest in reading a lot of technical details, you might find it difficult to get through. Also, the “problem solving aspect” of the book I thought was a little tiring. You could easily predict that there was going to be another problem to solve.
A curriculum link could be created whereby you can make a chart of all the obstacles Mark had to overcome. This chart could also be used in a book trailer to spark interest in the book. Also, overcoming obstacles could be a discussion point for overcoming obstacles in real life.
Verdict: A detailed and science based book that appeals to readers interested in science and quality writing. I would definitely include this book in my collection.
Nuts...I tried to put a photo of the book in my blog, however it did not work. I like to see a photo of the books people are talking about as it helps me remember the book.
DeleteThis book has strong YA crossover appeal, but was written for adults and marketed to them. I do agree that it's got some great examples of problem solving and would appeal to kids with an interest in space travel, engineering, and science. I loved the book, but then I'm a big sci-fi nerd.
DeleteI've been thinking of picking this one up, though not in my typical area of interest. I have to say that when my husband asked if I wanted to see the movie, I was not overly excited about it (though any movie can be redeemed by the presence of Matt Damon... but I digress.) I ended up REALLY liking the movie.. maybe not loving. There is enough of a good story to keep interest even for those who may not gravitate to the genre/subject. I wonder if you would include it in both middle and high school library?
DeleteMark Watney is an amusing and witty character. Both my son (18) and I laughed out loud at his comments and antics throughout this book. It provided an immensely enjoyable read for both of us.
DeleteTo answer Laura's question about including it in both middle and high school, I vote absolutely.
I think this would be an excellent teacher read aloud story for grades 4 and 5 at our STEM magnet. The story is not complex and while the technical information may go over the heads of younger readers, the teacher can help them put all the pieces together while highlighting the problem solving aspect of the adventure.
Laura, I think this book could be in both a middle and high school Library. It just depends on the reader and what level they are at. Some middle school students are reading at a high school level, therefore I would include it in a middle school library.
DeleteThe main character Mark Watney is amusing, entertaining, and enduring to readers, but the language takes away from the story for middle schoolers. For this reason, I think this book is better suited for the high school media center due to the language.
Delete"Six of Crows" by Leigh Barduro
ReplyDeleteThe beginning of a new fantasy series, "Six of Crows" follows Kaz Brekker - con artist, thief, ambitious gang leader - and his unlikely band of rogues as they take on an impossible mission. They must break into the impenetrable stronghold of Fjerda and save a chemist before he reveals the secret of a dangerous drug. If they do not succeed, rival countries will use the drug to abuse the powers of the magical Grisha and control the world.
This book has been much lauded, it's easy to see why. The stage is set with anti-heros, each driven with inner revenge, but each unique and relatable. There are no princes or princesses to be found on the streets of Ketterdam. Each character comes with secret strengths, gaping flaws, horrid pasts and hidden desires, and though none of them are honorable, they capture you with their stories as they embark on a mission they can't hope to return from.
The new series works in the same world as Barduro's previous "Grisha" series, but it operates independently in that world. Whether you liked, hated, or never heard of her other works (I fall in the 3rd category), this book has something for everyone.
Some may find the beginning of the book slow, as time is taken to introduce (or re-introduce) the world and it's characters. You won't know you're hooked until you try to put it down.
This book has a few dark themes such as indenture and slavery, prostitution, drugs, and a bit of a violent streak. It is often recommended for grades 8+. If any of our students enjoy fantasy and adventure, this is one to include on the shelf, especially in high school. In a middle school, consider your collection and audience - if your readers are drawn to mature, engaging plots, then I'd put this on your shelf too - I know I would have picked it up!
Verdict: Anti-heroes are the new princes! The strong characters and mysterious plot will keep this book off your shelves - but only if you put it there first!
I'm very involved in the young adult book blogging community and this book has a HUGE following. Lots and lots of positive reviews on it. A few that aren't thrilled with it, but over-all people seem to like it.
DeleteI'm curious about and really should step out of my comfort zone and read it. I didn't read her other series for the same reason - it's just not something I'd typically pick up. But because I've heard good things about, and I'd like to see if it's something I'd shelve I really should read it. From what you say about it, and knowing the readers at the middle school I was at, it is one they'd all really be drawn to.
Thanks for picking it for this class and sharing your thoughts.
Ellie -
DeleteThis was one of the books I requested but STILL haven't received it. I am intrigued by this one and plan to read it soon. Thank you for acknowledging the slow start. Without knowing that, I might have given up. Good thing to tell the future readers of this book.
Good to know about the slow start. It's helpful if you can tell students that but also tell them to hang in there. Sounds like a great new trend of anti-heroes!
DeleteBook title: The Testing by Joelle Charbonneau
ReplyDeletea. Audience for whom the book is written.
Middle school/high school students.
b. Audience for whom the book will appeal.
Anyone who likes Hunger Games and/or Divergent as this book is a cross between the two. It might appeal more to younger teens or those who are firmly set in the genre.
c. Strengths
This is a compelling story for teens and with plenty of action it will draw students in for sure especially those who like the genre. There is also a strong female protagonist who is smart and capable. The descriptions of the setting were interesting and the author gives plenty of background on the history of the country and what happened to it.
d. Weaknesses
It is a predictable story that seems to have too much in common with books that have come before it like Hunger Games and Divergent.
e. Special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.)
As with typical dystopian novels, the presence of an oppressive government that doesn’t seem to care about its citizens is the main focus of this text. In this case, the protagonist has no idea how oppressive the government is until she’s selected for testing and starts to see more of the world she’s been cut off from.
This is another text in which the characters are encouraged to fight each other in order to win, so there are some violent scenes throughout. There is also violence directly from government officials during the testing period as characters are punished for getting wrong answers.
f. Your verdict (with details): The Testing would be a good addition to any library collection as it will draw some students in and provide them with a strong female protagonist and an action-packed story line; however, I would not recommend buying too many copies of this predictable book.
Thanks for the tip. I'd agree 2 or 3 copies per book is probably enough. It hasn't been flying off the shelves like Cinder, The Selection, Hunger Games, Divergent or Maze Runner... but it might just get there if they make a movie out of it! I'd rather see Cinder as a movie first.
DeleteI would agree with that. Cinder would make a fun movie to see. I thought that was a great read. On another note, I did have some kids want to read The Testing as I brought it back to school and did a book talk on it. It is now in high demand in my classroom.
DeleteThanks for your review on this one. It's been around for awhile and when I shared it with my students not many picked it up. So I completely agree with your thoughts on not carrying too many copies if any.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete"The Martian" by Andy Weir
ReplyDeleteI envision this book appealing STEM high school students or students in a STEM course within a high school. Andy Weir's technical writing is fascinating and jam packed with details. Andy Weir was first hired as a programmer for a national laboratory at age fifteen. It mentions in the biography at the back of the book that he is a lifelong space nerd and enjoys hobbies such as relativistic physics, orbital mechanics, and the history of manned flight. The Martian was his first novel. The book was written for an upper middle-high school audience.
Strengths:
Andy Weir does a great job of explaining all the technical, mechanical and/or biological processes throughout the book. The book moves at a fast pace which makes it a fast interesting read. Mark Watney is a likable character because he is clever, witty, and has a sense of humor so you will find yourself rooting for him throughout the book.
Weaknesses:
There is predictability throughout the story. There is a catastrophic event, a moment of suspense, and then Mark Watney comes up with a clever solution and diverts the emergency.
This book is written technically rich and for students who are not mathematical or scientifically inclined I would worry that they would not make it past the first couple pages.
Verdict:
The language is vulgar at times and there is some sexual content. I believe that this would be a good addition to any high school or upper middle school library particularly for students interested in science, math, and/or engineering
Yes, the story is predictable however it demonstrates that no matter how many obstacles a person encounters, there is a possible solution. This is what I really liked about this book. I don't think you really need to be mathematical or scientifically minded to read the book. I think it is possible to understand what is happening without being a techie.
Delete"Every day," by David Levithan
ReplyDeleteThis story was strange. It kept my interest, but it was very hard for me to follow. I kept waiting for something more to happen. There is probably an underlying theme, but I have no idea what it is-I'm guessing I'm not smart enough! I can't figure out who would actually like this story. To sum it up, the main character is a spirit that moves to a different host body every day. One day, "it" falls in love with a teenage girl. They develop a relationship. The end.
Audience written for: Gr.8+
Audience appeals: ?
Strengths: The story is interesting enough to keep me reading. The characters live life in a relatable way to the reader, with the exception of "A" whom moves from body to body every day. Meaning, they attend school, parties, etc. The author uses language that the audience can follow.
Weaknesses: Personally, I couldn't connect with the story or any of the characters. I kept waiting for something big to happen to help me understand what was going on.
Final Verdict: The story was just ok for me. I can't seem to find a way that readers would connect with it. I don't see a purpose to reading it.
I can see how some may find it difficult to connect with the premise of this story. Levithan asks the reader to consider the notion that a being can exist only in a form of consciousness manifesting themselves to humans only when they are a parasite on another human being. A has no body, no gender, no sexuality. A wakes up in a different stranger’s body every morning and has to live their life for a day, until A is whisked away at midnight only to repeat the process again tomorrow. A tries not to interfere too much in people’s lives, until he meets Rhiannon, falls in love, and starts to break the rules one by one and as he does so, the reader is faced with the question, What makes each of us an individual - what makes me, "me"?
DeleteAudience for whom written: Ages 14-18
Audience for whom appeals: Ages 14-18 who like to contemplate life’s big questions. I think it appeals equally to boys and girls. The asexual nature of A may appeal to LGBTQ students.
Strengths:
• Although each ‘host’ is sixteen years old, each has a very different story to tell. The number of “types” that are addressed by the various bodies that A inhabits allows the students to consider how they view/judge those types – obese, female, male, rich, poor,
Weaknesses:
• For those who are not fans of the fantasy genre, this really asks you to accept the ability to exist only as a consciousness – without any substance beyond a parasitic existence.
Special Considerations:
• The ending leaves many unanswered questions. Although Every Day is, on the surface, a simple idea, it throws up a lot of complicated questions. What defines who you are? Is gender a silly concept? What about sexuality? Is A doing something morally wrong? Is it better to experience many different things, or see a few the whole way through?
• A takes very good care of the bodies he inhabits – following the concept of time travelers – don’t make changes or alter the life of the person. A does interfere, however, to help one girl who is contemplating suicide.
• This book has been used successfully as an all school read for incoming college freshmen allowing the student body to discuss the deeper issues mentioned above.
Verdict:
I would include this in my high school library and probably a middle school library depending on your student demographics.
I love a book that gets kids to think deeply! I have wanted to read this one because I thought the premise was so unique and I like David Levithan. Thanks for your review!
DeleteBook title: Shiver by Maggie Stiefvater
ReplyDeleteThis book was written for and will definitely appeal to middle and high school students, especially those who like supernatural characters like werewolves.
c. Strengths
The female protagonist, Grace, leads this story about a girl who was attacked by a pack of werewolves early in her life and was saved by one. This ignites her love of wolves and feels drawn to them over the years, not realizing that they are actually werewolves. She later meets the werewolf who saved her long ago in his human form and they fall in love. As a character, Grace is strong and steadfast in her love of the animals and her desire to protect her new love. While this storyline is obviously not plausible, it is an interesting twist to the typical teenage romance, at least for those who like this subgenre. Again, outside the werewolf concept, the teens and their choices, their behavior is believable as they run around trying to find a new werewolf gone rogue. Finally, the writing is good and descriptive in both the natural setting and of the teens’ interactions with the other characters. In fact, the writing is a much higher quality than other popular supernatural fantasy books, such as Twilight, that have been more popular.
d. Weaknesses
Shiver is somewhat predictable, especially once one has already read the countless other werewolf and vampire books available. I could guess what was coming before it came and I would suspect or even expect the well-read teen would too. The unfortunate thing about this is that Shiver is one of many books in this subgenre and it can get overlooked.
e. Special considerations
The reader needs to be open to this concept of werewolves and accept the story as it is, a fantasy. The idea of love across “species” is not new at all, but this story hinges on it and the predictable nature of how this story progresses. There are suggestions of teen sex, but nothing graphic is described. However, there is a lot of violence as werewolves are attacking people or showing victims after they have been attacked. Often YA literature includes adult figure who are weak or nonexistent and in this case, Grace’s parents are present very little in the story and are often portrayed as a secondary set of antagonists. It is definitely teens and werewolves against the world in this story.
f. Your verdict (with details): The whole Shiver trilogy will be a good addition to your library as, if nothing else, it will give teens who are into this genre another set of books to keep them going.
oh my goodness, i loved, loved this book! i couldn't put it down and immediately started the sequel (which i didn't like as much-i'm about to start the last one) while the story is fantasy, there were still realistic and relatable parts. i think teenage girls can definitely connect to grace-heck, i could, thinking back to meeting my first love.
Deletegreat review michelle.
I loved these books too. Great for those teens that have already read "Twilight" and other supernatural series. And this series can be a gateway into other fantastic books by Maggie Stiefvater including "The Scorpio Races" (my favorite!), "Lament" and "Ballad" (fairies), and the Raven Boys series.
DeleteI agree with Michelle that the book is predictable for an adult reader and I have to wonder if a teen may find comfort in that. They can have so much unpredictability in their social circles that a book like this, with a simple plot trajectory, offers a safe place to hang out for a while.
DeleteA strength for this book stems from the author's link to music, art and writing. Stiefvater is herself a songwriter and the lyrics she includes are pretty good (in the audio book they are read lyrically and it adds a nice touch to the story). I think you could entice some reluctant readers to the series through the musical aspects of the book.
I was immediately curious about the chapter titles and the fact that they include the temperature. I found myself checking these and referring back to them as the mystery of the wolves unfolded. It would be interesting to draw students into the series by asking them to predict when the temperature will drop below a certain point - a media center contest of sorts.
Students near Duluth will relate to the location and may enjoy trying to place Mercy Falls.
Like Jessica, I was intrigued enough with the story to immediately read the second book, Linger. I will read the 3rd book in hopes that the story redeems itself. I found the boy obsession in the 2nd book over the top but now I have to find out what happens. I believe teens will have the same reaction and that will keep them reading - always a good thing!
Verdict: I would definitely include the series in a high school collection and focus on some of the unique aspects of music and the Minnesota setting to draw readers attention to the series.
By far...my favorite book from this class! I simply cannot wait to read the rest of the trilogy. Even though I did find the plot to be predictable, I found that comforting. It was a good, clean read. Captured my interest immediately and held it the entire time. Glad you enjoyed it, too!
DeleteOn a Clear Day
ReplyDeleteBy Walter Dean Myers
Written for: High School Audience
Strengths: Set in the year 2035, the protagonist, Dahlia (16), is learning to survive in a world that is controlled by 8 major corporations known as the C-8. Dahlia has a strong sense of who she is and how she relates with a world that is both controlled and segregated by C-8 until she is sought out by Michael. Michael, former band singer and financially rich, is putting together a group of 7 teens to take on the C-8 corporation. Each member has a certain strength of their own.
Weaknesses: Although the book is set in the years 2035, very little is explained to detail. The setting is very vague. The same could be said of the characters, too. At the beginning, Dahlia is presented with information on each character and what he/she brings to the table. I wish more of this would have played out throughout the story. The entire plot seems to be a mile wide and only centimeters deep. I found it very difficult to connect with any of the characters or to see how they were to work together. This is also true of the understanding of C-8 and their part in the story. At no time does Dahlia or her group members come in contact with this world dominating organization.
Special Considerations:
I would rate this book for the High School audience only because it is a difficult storyline to follow.
Verdict: 2 stars - I would not recommend this book for a library collection. The storyline was all over the place and never quite came together. The characters are not well developed and I don't quite understand where it falls within the Sci-Fi category.
Talley I hadn't heard of this one by WDM. Sorry to hear it wasn't that good since so many of his books are high quality. I too have a hard time with a book when I cannot connect to the characters. Thanks for reading and sharing.
DeleteTalley I hadn't heard of this one by WDM. Sorry to hear it wasn't that good since so many of his books are high quality. I too have a hard time with a book when I cannot connect to the characters. Thanks for reading and sharing.
DeleteJill -
DeleteEverything I read about WDM, online, shared the same viewpoints as you. Sounds like he was a great author and so many of his books were of high interest. This one was a dud. I think it was because he tried to make so many "connections" with a variety of issues and didn't give them the attention or time needed. If I am remembering correctly, I believe this was one of his last books before passing away. I'll have to check in on that!
The Girl Who Could Silence the Wind by Meg Medina
ReplyDeleteGrades 5 and up--
Rooted in folklore with hints of mystery, magical realism and young love, The Girl Who Could Silence the Wind by Meg Medina tells the story of a small town that believes that one of their own has the power to change their futures, but for her, the pressure has become too much and she has to make a decision to
Intended audience:
According to Medina’s site, she aimed to write a telenovela style story for kids of all ages. I would say more specifically upper elementary students, boys and girls, Spanish speakers.
Audience to whom it may appeal: I think that the novel may appeal to kids and adults alike, those who are interested in a coming of age tale with a few twists and turns. It may also appeal to those interested in learning about magical realism and perhaps those interested in studying the Spanish language.
Strengths: The time and place of the tale is obscure enough that it could be anywhere at anytime which lends it to a unique experience for each and every reader. Its timeless themes of family, perseverance and love make for a relatable read for all types of readers.
Weaknesses: While the obscurity of the setting may be enjoyable for readers with strong imaginative skills, some might find the lack of descriptive language hard to picture and follow. There is a sprinkling of Spanish phrases throughout the novel that might discourage readers with no prior knowledge of the language or cultural practices.
VERDICT: An allegory for finding the balance between family and following your heart, this novel would be an excellent addition to an elementary or middle school library for students seeking a story with soul.
"The Maze Runner" by James Dashner
ReplyDeleteI envision this book appealing to middle school students seeking an adventure series. The characters are realistic and relatable yet the setting is mysterious and imaginative.
Strengths:
The male protagonist, Thomas, is a likable character because he is quick-witted, kind-hearted and has a sense of humor. You will sympathize and find yourself cheering him on throughout the book. The adventure and fast pace of this novel makes it a quick read. The ending definitely leaves you longing for answers and craving the next book in the series to see what’s going to happen next.
Weaknesses:
The similarities between The Hunger Games and The Maze Runner are prominent. The setting in both series is a post-apocalyptic world with a young teenage hero standing up to fight for their life against the rulers.
Verdict:
I believe that this would be a good addition to any middle school library particularly for students interested in dystopian novels. For students who were intrigued by The Hunger Games and Divergent series this would be another series that would capture their attention. There is violence throughout the book with certain parts a bit more goory than others. I would be sure to use that as a disclaimer when recommending.
This is another very popular series in my media center. When Scorch Trials was released as a movie, there was a lot of hype in the middle school. I personally enjoyed the first book and found the descriptions of the Grievers to be creepy enough to stick with you even after closing the cover.
DeleteKino No Tabi: Book One of the Beautiful World by Keiichi Sigsawa
ReplyDeleteGenre: Fantasy Fiction
Pages: 208
Published: TokyoPop in 2016
The story is based around a girl named Kino and her talking motorcycle Hermes. She rides the motorcycle from town to town, only staying in each place for exactly three days. In this volume, Kino comes across a democratic ghost town, a scientifically advanced town of empathy, and a town where you are only granted entrance after winning a fight to the death.
Audience:
This book will capture the interest of anime and manga fans, especially since it’s been made into an animated TV series. It could be read from sixth grade to twelfth grade.
Strengths:
The towns and short stories present very strong, parallel metaphors to the world today. The reader learns a new moral lesson in each town that Kino visits. These lessons can easily be understood by younger students because they are portrayed on a smaller, more tangible, scale. This makes for a great starting point in discussions. Also, there is a bit of mystery shrouding each village, so the reader is always wondering what happens next.
Weaknesses:
The book is a collection of five to six short stories of Kino’s experiences in various towns. The stories are not connected and do not directly build off of each other. There are also parts of the plot that are left unexplained and are most likely retouched further along in the series. This may leave the reader feeling that the story is very disjointed.
Special Considerations:
There are a few violent scenes throughout the book. In the opening town, a man is stabbed to death protecting a girl from her parent, who are trying to kill her. There is a man who has ordered everyone in his village executed. And in the final town, people are killing each other in order to gain entrance into a town. Kino is also very skilled with a gun and uses it throughout the book to protect herself.
Verdict:
This book would be a great addition to a middle or high school media center. Sigsawa skillfully twists fantasy and realistic ideas to create a book that causes you to think deeper about the humanity of humanity.
City of Ember by Jeanne Duprau
ReplyDeleteAge Level: 8-12
Grades: 3-7
The City of Ember is a city that is completely lit by lightbulbs. There are no sun, moon, or stars. The city is run by a large generator that is on its last legs. The two main characters, Lina Mayfleet and Doon Harrow try to discover ways to save the city and also escape successfully. Little do they know that the original founders of Ember had eventual escape plans drawn out for future Ember citizens. Those lost plans were discovered by Lina not in there original form.
Strengths: Duprau does an excellent job of mixing a science-fiction story with andventure and intrigue. You find yourself cheering on Lina and Doon to solve the mysterious plans to exit Ember. Duprau leaves you enough clues to try to solve the riddle on your own, but not enough to actually solve it.
Weakness: If you do not like cliff hangers, you will be disappointed in the end. You must read the first chapter of next book, "People of Sparks," to see what happens. Others may find this a strength of the book. The movie is dreadful. Don't ever see it. I only imagine that Jeanne Duprau gave up her creative rights on the move.
Verdict: Any reader will enjoy this book. High schoolers would also enjoy this book! It's one of my favorite reads! Even readers that do not enjoy the science fiction genre will enjoy this book.
Loved this book, and yes kids like it too. It's a good one to give to them after they've made their way through some of the other dystopia OR if they are younger and maybe not ready for The Hunger Games. It's tamer. Have you read the others in the series? I wasn't as impressed by them - especially the prequel. I also found that kids didn't like them as much. From a media specialist perspective I'd have them in the media center (the sequels), but I wouldn't have very many copies.
DeleteTitle: Fairest: Levana's Story
ReplyDeleteBy: Marissa Meyer
Age recommendation: 12-17
Audience to whom it will appeal: Wide range of science fiction, fantasy, fairy tale readers. Predominantly appeals to female readers. Readers who’ve enjoyed the Lunar Chronicles Series.
Strengths of Book: Meyer takes the reader to another world, another planet in Luna a moon colony where magic, “glamour,” love, deceit, death, and heartache control the characters. Fairest: Levana’s Story is a well-crafted spin on the evil queen from the fairytale Snow White. Readers are not sure if they should cheer on Levana in her misguided quest for acceptance, love, and power; or if they should dislike her for her evil, unforgiving, and manipulative nature.
Weaknesses of Book: At times the plot drags and the dynamics between the main character Levana and her husband, Evret are strained and boring. The love story turns more to a melodrama causing Levana to lose some of her edge.
Special Considerations: The subject matter does contain some cautionary aspects such as brutality, murder, sex (although not explicit), and mutilation.
Verdict: Overall this book is a creative look at familiar fairy tales and the ultimate struggle between good and evil. Through Levana’s life, readers are able to dive into a world that is rooted in falsehoods where people hide behind “glamours” and find empathy with truly good characters. I would place this book in the middle school media center as it is a vital part of the Lunar Chronicles and completes the series.