The graphic novel is written for students from grade 3 and up. It is a series of graphic novel and Old Ma's Cave is volume 6 in the series. The graphic novel might be more appealing to young boys and those who love the bone series. The strengths of the graphic novel is that it teaches the reader about unity, family, friendship, loyalty, humor and life lesson. It also an easy read as the graphic novel is divided into chapters. The weakness of the books is that some of the speech bubbles letter type are small especially for the villant in the book. It was a little hard for me to read. ( Must be my old eye). The art work beautiful. The color are vibrant and the illustration of the characters shows shadowing in light and darkness.
Verdict: This would be a huge hit for fan's of Bone series. A must have in graphic novel collection!
I'm not sure I would have the Bone series in the elementary school. Grades 3 and up? Middle and high school yes. My husband is a huge fan of this series. Our 7 year old was interested in the book. Husband read it long ago and forgot about the sexual tension in Book 1 of Bone seeing Thorn bathing and getting excited about that and of Bone's love interest in Thorn. Ok for secondary level students, but elementary. . . I wouldn't buy it for an elementary media center. That's my only issue with it. Good stories, international popularity--yes, a must-have for secondary media centers.
I borrowed BONE from my 3-5 Primary school. It is frequently checked out by students and often challenged by parents. At first, I found it difficult to get into. The story felt complicated at the beginning but as it went on, I found myself getting involved in the plot. I even giggled outloud a few times. All in all, I enjoyed the story more than I thought I would.
I've been debating about whether Bone is appropriate for my elementary school. I worry because my younger students love checking out the graphic novels. But I also remember my son loving this series in elementary school. Still considering..
Book title: Relish: My Life in the Kitchen by Lucy Knisley
a. Audience for whom the book is written. This book is not kept in the YA section of the library, as it is a graphic novel. It is meant for adults initially, I think. However, I got the title of this book from the ALEX website – an adult book that is also aimed at teens. Really, the sense I get from the author is that it is meant for anyone who loves food, no matter what the age.
b. Audience for whom the book will appeal. Teens may not gravitate to this book unless they are already into food and food preparation. There is an interesting storyline as the author is telling her life story, highlighting the connection between food and family memories.
c. Strengths There is humor and honesty in the retelling of her family history. A particular event she shares is about a trip to Mexico when her mom and her mom’s friend got sick as soon as they arrived and spent four days in bed recovering. Meanwhile, the kids were left to fend for themselves, even roaming the streets alone, and later the author recognizes how crazy it sounds for mothers to encourage their preteens to run around a foreign city alone. An additional strength is that this book also comes with a number of recipes also in graphic novel format, which seems to make them more fun and inviting. The author gives suggestions for several of these recipes, so readers can personalize the food to their own tastes. The stories of her childhood, teen years, and young adult years are wound together very thoughtfully and they complement each other nicely.
d. Weaknesses Being mostly about food, this is a specialized topic and may not get much in the way of usage in every library.
e. Special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.) The author makes a direct connection between food and family in this text. She demonstrates a love for food and how it’s intertwined in her memories. The reader can certainly learn how to make a few things, the social aspect of food, and a variety of dishes from around the world. There is a distinct message about being open to new experiences and especially foods. Finally, there is encouragement for readers not to worry about perfection.
The artwork is very simple and colorful whether in the narrative portions of the text or in the recipes. The text and storyline are easy to follow.
Within the story of the tip to Mexico, as the kids are exploring the city they find cheap porn and the protagonist’s best friend buys a lot over the course of the four days their mothers are sick. There are some pictures of the covers of these magazines as the author describes their surprise that these magazines are not hidden like they are in the U.S. The drawings are clearly female and nude. Parents may take issue with this depending on where they book is housed and the age of the reader.
f. Your verdict (with details): This is a lovely memoir with an honesty about the author’s past as well as her love for food. The personal stories are entertaining, and the recipes have the potential to get teens into the kitchen. While this book will be enjoyed by a smaller audience, it would be a worthwhile addition to a library.
I love this book, but I read it for myself. I agree with you that it will have a limited audience since it was not originally written for YA readers. However, the right book display can get this one to circulate I'm sure. I think it would be good to let English teachers know about if students have any memoir writing assignments. This would be a good example of one way (one very creative way) to go about it.
I have also found that there are a number of kids who do like to cook and bake. I think this would definitely be a good one for them. They need to see that there are others with like-minds.
This graphic novel is written fro students in grade 5 to grade 9. It would appeal to students who love the Percy Jackson series and love Greek mythology. The strength of the book is that the illustration and coloring of the graphic is totally awesome. The speech bubble changes shapes when there is some action going on with characters. The weakness of the books is that there are too many graphic strips cram in one page. I just wish it was spread a little more. The cover of the books is beautifully done with artwork of the characters of the books such as Percy Jackson and the lightning bolt.
Verdict: If you have the Percy Jackson series, the graphic novel is a must especially a Maud hart Lovelace award winner. It would be a huge it just like the books.
I agree with you on this one. For those kids that love Percy Jackson (and there are many!) this is a great book to add. I like that it might push a kid that read only regular novels to pick up and read a graphic novel. I know some thing graphic novels are simple and easy to read, but I've found them to be more difficult than I thought. And I think that kids feel the same. But having a book that they know just put into graphic form might open them up to this genre and get them reading it more.
Agreed! This book is wildly popular in my media center because of all the Percy Jackson fans. I think students get a different feel from the graphic novel than they do the book. I only have the first two, but there are students asking me if there are others. There's only four, right?
This graphic novel is listed for Grade 5 and up. I would agree that this is an appropriate age, all the way up to adults, who will enjoy reminiscing of what it was like to be a teen in the 90's. The only inappropriate content for 5th graders is that Raina's friends play spin-the-bottle at a party during their 8th grade year.
Strengths of the book are in the comic-style artwork, often humorous at times, as well as the truth in story-telling for a self-proclaimed "nerdy" teen who is easily relatable to readers. Teen girls especially will be able to relate to Raina's beauty struggles, orthodontic trauma, and various other scenes involving friends, dating and career aspirations.
Weaknesses are in the drastic age progression from middle school through high school; that as she gets older, there are more party and dating references, such as playing spin the bottle. Also, there are large jumps in time that may confuse younger readers.
Special considerations include the comic-style artwork, the setting in San Francisco, as well as the fact that Raina herself is the protagonist in the story.
Verdict: A delightful read for middle and high school audiences, both male and female. You will likely need multiple copies on hand to meet demand.
My daughter (grade 5) has read this numerous times and loves it. In fact, I was thinking of picking it up as my choice book (but think I will now do "Sisters" -also by R. Telgemeier- instead.) I wasn't sure if it was a little too "young" for the YA lit category, so glad to read your assessment of it.
First published as a monthly serial DC comic Vertigo imprint in 1988, the Sandman by Neil Gaiman and illustrated by Sam Kieth, Mike Dringenberg, Jill Thompson, et al. is a dark, urban fantasy novel in graphic format that explores the metaphysical topics in the realm of dreams. It has achieved a cult classic status and is arguably a valuable and collectible work. The intended audience for this collection is the mature comic book fan, older teens through adults. I believe this collection, now 27 years old, still appeals to true fans of the comic/graphic novel community (mostly male); however, given the expansion of the format (graphic novels are a format, not a genre) and with that, the broadening of the audience, Sandman will appeal to a number of individuals who enjoy fantasy, gothic horror, and mythopoetic narratives.
The strength of the Sandman series is the intrigue of the Sandman, the Lord of Dreams, himself. This character is Gaiman’s own reimagining of an old DC comic character long forgotten by the late 1980s when Gaiman summoned this immortal being into literary existence. One need not be acquainted with the stories of the past to immediately get sucked into this new rendition and its opening scene of an occult ceremony in an English manor house, circa 1925. In addition to excellent character development, a sophisticated plot sprinkled with literary and historical references, the art work is phenomenal. Pages explode with action and present various viewpoints; there are no boring or formulaic layouts. The riveting presentation engages the reader throughout the narrative. Dave McKean’s cover art for each installment is eerie and fantastical—smoky mirrors, death masks, and murky laboratory jars filled with various specimens. These elements help to conjure up a supernatural atmosphere and a feeling of suspended animation and paralyzing fear one associates with nightmares.
There are references to other DC comic characters and plots that the uninitiated will not catch, but these small gaps do not interfere holistically with the story telling. Another possible weakness may be found in the lack of foreshadowing regarding the Sandman’s sibling in the few scenes where the Sandman’s dreamers die during the first eight issues of the series, now bound as a collection titled Preludes and Nocturnes.
Special considerations: Gaiman is no amateur. He is a master storyteller, poetic, and clever in his references to literary figures Biblical and otherwise. This text is not for the causal reader, nor the faint of heart. It is full of gruesome imagery and diabolical situations. There is sex; there is violence; and the presentation is unapologetic. We are talking heaven and hell here, and the marriage of art and narrative that makes this series explode is amazing and sophisticated.
Verdict: As a K-12 library media specialist, I cannot in good conscious recommend this series to a minor. I cannot imagine the series in an elementary or middle school, and would be surprised to find it in a high school. I believe Gaiman’s intended audience was the adult comic fan base; and as a result of the quality and popularity of his work, the Sandman series has gained a devoted fan base of younger readers. I am ok with that. Readers who crave this type of narrative will find this series, but I personally do not feel compelled to actively promote or guide anyone under age 18 to this series.
“This One Summer” by Jillian Tamaki & Mariko Tamaki
“This One Summer” is a graphic novel about the transition from child to young adult. This quiet book is written for teens and preteens. Older teens may be put off by the younger characters. Preteens that are ready to read about the older topics such as sex, drinking, teen pregnancy, and depression may also choose this to read. I think it will appeal to girls more than boys due to it’s purple cover, pink spine, and female main characters. It would also appeal to reluctant readers.
Strengths: The biggest strengths in this graphic novel are the illustrations. The illustrator portrays the very real emotions of each character in a quiet, yet poignant way. I am amazed how much emotion can be seen in two-color illustrations. I also thought the characters felt very real. Like this is exactly what girls this age would be doing and how they would be acting. Rose was a slob and very overdramatic. I felt like her reactions were spot on.
Weaknesses: One of the reasons I am not a huge fan of graphic novels is because I want more story. It’s just not enough for me. I felt the same way with this one especially since there was very little plot. It was a very quiet glimpse of a girl’s summer. It showed more character development than story.
Verdict: I think this graphic novel would be an appropriate purchase for both middle and high school libraries. The artwork is beautiful and expressive. It would be a good “next step” for students that enjoyed graphic novels like “Smile” and “Sisters” when they were younger.
I too read this book, and I agree about the way she portrays emotions in a very poignant way and was also surprised at the emotion that was conveyed in two-color illustrations.
I read this one, too. I agree. The illustrations are wonderful! I thought it was a good story. One of which, many could relate to. I remember being a young girl and feeling many of the same things as Rose and Windy. I could also relate to the mother in the story. I think all of can connect to the story in our own way. We often judge people from the outside, without knowing their "story." I think this book is filled with that. Again, I agree. I was hoping for more at the end, also. I think this book would be a great fit in the middle school or high school.
This stunning graphic novel is compact, but powerful. The artwork is similar to the stark black and white drawings of Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis and illustrate the divided world in which she lives: Beirut, Lebanon in the 1980s and 1990s. Written like a list poem, with each page or so beginning with “I Remember,” Abirached tells the story of her life growing up in a war zone.
Intended audience: Young adults interested in history.
Audience to whom it may appeal: I think this book could appeal to upper elementary students to grandparents, of all genders, races and religions. Its universal themes of memory and perseverance through struggle have the potential to provide connections for many.
Strengths: The artwork is visually very appealing. The solid black and white images are simple but captivating. The poetic style and repetition makes it accessible for a wider variety of audiences.
Weaknesses: Without much historical context, this book might be hard to understand, but it can also stand on its own as a story of a young girl’s life and all of the things she experienced. Although the prose and dialogue are relatively simplistic, there are historical and cultural references that will likely be missed by students with little background knowledge.
Special considerations: The book is a companion to A Game for Swallows which focuses on one particular night during war time.
VERDICT: This book would make a great addition to either the graphic novel or history section of any upper elementary through high school media center. The accessible format will appeal to lower readers, while the historical content might entice higher level readers to try a new format: graphic novel.
I've had this book sitting on my shelf for a little bit. The other night I was going through my books and saw. It looked quick, and I knew it had been a Newbery Honor book, so I decided it was time to read it. 3 hours later I had finished it!
It was really good. I loved how it gave an inside view of how it feels to been seen as different and how much she just wanted to be seen as just like everyone else. I mean we all know this, but this story gave me a glimpse at the inner dialog of a young girl going growing up feeling that way. It truly helped me gain a clearer understanding.
I've had students that use the amplifier talked about in the book. So the whole part of the story where Cece can hear the teacher using it even when she's out of the classroom made me giggle because we were told to make sure to turn it off for certain situations. Using the bathroom was one situation we were told clearly to make sure we turned it off! So when Cece can hear her teacher in the bathroom, it really made me giggle!
This is a book I could see myself recommending to many middle schoolers. It had a good message, it is semi-autobiographical, it is funny, and it has a good message. Having a book that combines all that is wonderful because kids will enjoy the story and walk away with better understanding of the people around them. PLUS - they can relate to Cece just wanting to have a good friend. Aren't all middle schoolers looking for that? I couldn't ask for anything more.
Final thought: Quick, fun and teachable but completely relatable. One that I would for sure add to my media center.
Jill - I read El Deafo last summer and instantly connected with CeCe. As a classroom teacher, I often wore the special mic that went directly to a student's ear piece. And, sadly, I am also guilty of forgetting to turn it off. I accidentally purchased it for my K-2 school last year. After reading it, I felt it would get more attention at the 3-5 elementary.
I laughed at the part where the teacher forgot to turn the mic off too because it happens all the time at my school! Elementary kids enjoy this story too. I have it in my K-5 school.
Sisters- by Raina Talgemeier One of the reasons I wanted to read Sisters is to find out what all the fuss was about among my daughter and her friends. At last year’s school book fair, she just HAD to have it (along with Smile, also by Talgemeier—see Mandy’s blog post.) The audience is upper elementary to middle school. It would appeal to grades 4-6 in particular, I believe, though readers all the way through high school may enjoy it for a quick, easy read. The main character, Raina, is preparing for the transition to high school, which is another factor that could expand the audience to high school. I found no “inappropriate” content or anything remotely “challenge-able” in the book. Strengths of the book are its fast pace (again, for those looking for a quick easy read.) Something to note, however, is that even with its fast pace, some bigger topics are explored, such as family dynamics, family change, and job loss. The way these bigger issues are discussed is lighthearted enough so that students who do not necessarily want an overly emotional read will find that Sisters meets that criteria. Raina has an authentic voice, and the sibling rivalry/ bickering is portrayed in a way that most readers (with siblings, that is) will likely find relatable. Weaknesses: The story jumps from past to present in a way that is not always seamless. Overall, the technique of jumping from past to present adds to the story—and is integral to the story, I might add-- but in a couple instances, the transition is clumsy and may be difficult for younger or struggling readers to follow. Special considerations: The road trip is a central component of the story, and the geographical information is an added bonus. The family has some “unfortunate” luck with pets, which Talgemeier weaves throughout the story. There is a mention of possible divorce, and the sisters grapple with this possibility. Again, it is mentioned and comes out more as a minor detail in the end, but gives the story just enough depth to encourage some thought about our own families (e.g.- What does it mean when parents fight? How does a job loss affect a relationship? etc.) Verdict: I would include multiple copies in any elementary or middle school library. I would include it in a high school library as well, but with fewer copies than at the younger grades. While it will likely appeal more to female students, some male students will read Sisters as well.
This book would appeal to middle school students both boys and girls alike. I would recommend this book to students that like fantasy novels set in another world and are looking for a good creepy ghost story.
Strengths: Once you get past the murder scene on the first page you find that The Graveyard Book could really act as a metaphor about growing up. As kids grow up they learn about the "outside" world beyond their protective homes and begin to have curious questions and what life is really life. Bod (short for Nobody) is the protagonist in the book who is taken in by ghosts in the graveyard as he is left with no one to look after him when his family is murdered. As he grows up he begins to have ambitions to explore beyond the graveyard walls.
Weaknesses: The title and the cover of the book should prepare the reader for a creepy story. However, if those signals were not caught in the title and front cover of the book the first page could be a bit much for a child not expecting such a squeamish story. If you do get past the first page there is nothing else as squeamish besides the spookiness of ghosts, vampire-like characters, monsters, and a creepy setting of a graveyard and a little boy being raised by ghosts. If a reader is looking for these things they will LOVE this book.
Verdict: I would include a few copies in the middle school collection for those into ghost stories. The murder of Bod's family is the first page of the book, but it is immediate and what is left is a fantasy novel that will appeal to girls and boys alike looking for a ghost story.
This graphic novel holds its own against the full version of the book (which won the Newbery Award in 2009). For many readers, the graphic depictions may clear up some confusing aspects of the written word while adding a touch of humor but it also takes away some of the mystery. For example, at the start of the novel, it isn’t completely clear what type of creature Silas is; but when he first appears in the graphic novel (including the cover), there is no doubt. The reader loses out on a delicious moment of tension and wonder due to the clear visual presentation. On the other hand, there are elements in the graphic novel that benefit from the illustrations such as the descent into the world of the ghouls and the dance Macabray.
The Library Journal Review indicates that this title is for grades 5 and up. I can see the appeal of this graphic novel extending to lower grade levels for students who like ghost stories and spooky content but would caution its inclusion in an elementary library due to an opening bloody scene that may give younger students nightmares if they happen to pull it off the shelf and glance through the illustrations (special consideration).
The strength of this graphic novel lies in the fact that Gaiman is an expert storyteller and has first class illustrators to help him tell his tale. The pictures and the supporting dialogue/explanations are a combination of complex and simple words. A striving reader will find guidance in the illustrations if they struggle with the wording while at the same time, confusing illustrations are clarified through the descriptive wording.
Another strength lies in the fact that each chapter is like a short story that builds to a problematic climax and finds resolution. Although the overall story builds from chapter to chapter, a reader can enjoy the graphic novel in short installments. This also allows for the original novel to be split into two graphic novels – a point of consideration for the media specialist. There is much talk about Gaiman writing a follow-up to the Graveyard Book and some readers of the original book may think that the 2nd Volume of the graphic novel is that long awaited follow-up. Be prepared to help student overcome disappointment but make sure you order both volumes!
A weakness may be found in the complexity of the story. The character of the Man Jack is mysterious even in the full novel version of this tale. The graphic novel does nothing to clarify this mystery and may leave some readers confused (thus the desire by many to have a follow up novel to The Graveyard Book).
Verdict: This is a must have graphic novel for middle school and high school media centers. There is depth and intrigue to the story while at the same time a simplicity in each "short story" chapter of Bod’s life in the graveyard. Multiple levels of readers will find this graphic novel enjoyable giving it broad appeal, ensuring that it will receive good circulation.
I also read this book and found I enjoyed the graphic more than the novel. The strengths of the graphic are definitely in the pictures that bring the characters and scenes to life. I agree that the first images are tough to look at and I found myself quickly skipping over them. The content of the story is very thick and leaves the reader wanting to know more. My inherited media center collection has both copies of the graphic novels and 4 copies of the novel. The graphics are checked out with more frequency than the novel. I would include this book in the collection due to it's visual storytelling appeal and scary subject nature which seems to be a good sell to most middle school readers.
Boxers & Saints by Gene Luen Yang (2 graphic novels - they come as a set) Genre: Graphic Novel - Historical Pages: Boxers - 325 / Saints - 170 Published: 2013 by First Second
Boxers is about Bao, a chinese son, who learns a special ritual that gives him the strength to slay his enemies. On his journey to save China, he meets a woman and falls in love. He eventually becomes the leader of the Society of Righteous and Harmonious Fists and leads the organization to the Chinese capital.
Saints is about Four-Girl, a chinese daughter, who is constantly belittled and mistreated as a child. In her suffering, she decides to live up to those expectations and take up the challenge of becoming a “devil.” This path leads her to convert to the Christian faith. As a Christian in China, she is forced to move into a more isolated village with other Christians. Eventually, the Society of Righteous and Harmonious Fists attack her church.
Audience: These books could be read by anyone age twelve and up. Some of the vocabulary is difficult and culturally specific, but a student could still understand the story without those words. The fact that it is a graphic novel also makes it of interest to younger readers and even struggling readers.
Strengths: As a set, Boxers and Saints gives two sides of a violent and religiously extreme historical event. The story is set in China during the Boxer Rebellion, in which a secret Chinese organization led a rebellious uprising against western and Japanese influences. These graphic novels give history a touch of emotion and an adventurous backstory.
In Boxers, Bao has the best intentions behind his actions. But sometimes, those intentions lead him into doing horrifying acts. His remorse and guilt haunt his dreams. It is very apparent that he struggles between the rights and wrong of the uprising. Bao’s love interest is a very strong female character. She takes up her sword despite all the negative doubters.
In Saints, you connect and sympathize with Four-Girl from the very beginning of the book.This is the hook for readers to continue reading and stay engaged in the story to the very end.
Weaknesses: Both reads are so short and leave you wanting to know more. There are a few times when you think that a part of the storyline will lead to something larger, but it doesn’t. There just isn’t enough room in a graphic novel to fit all the tiny details and subplots.
Special Considerations: In Boxers, Bao’s father gets beat up by western officers to the point where he becomes mute and lethargic. There is also quite a bit of violence, killing, and death by sword. A severed human head is depicted as a sign of battle victory. A mother is murdered in front of her daughter and granddaughter.
In Saints, Four-Girl has suicidal thoughts at the age of eight and thinks of herself as a devil. She also endures physical and verbal abuse from her grandfather, uncle, and mother. There is also a character that murders a man and then is attacked by someone who uses a knife to slice whiskers into his cheeks.
Verdict: Gene Luen Yang has created a fictionalized and accurate retelling of the Boxer Rebellion. The graphic novels come together flawlessly to paint a clear picture of what it meant to be on either side of this uprising. Readers are left with an understanding that there are no winners when it comes to violence such as this. This historical graphic novel set is a must-have in middle and high school media centers - make sure to purchase them as a set.
My daughter who is a huge history buff was interested in these when we met Gene. She has them, but I don't know if she has read them yet. Thanks for sharing your views on them. I never thought about whether I'd put them in the media center, and your review has put my mind thinking about them in that way.
Beautiful Darkness By Fabien Vehlmann & Kerrascoet Genre: Graphic Novel - Fantasy Published 2014 (originally in French then translated)
A twist of a fairy tale where good vs. evil is not always obvious. Princess Aurora is swept away from the comforts of home to a dream-like land where she is forced to survive. In her typical "princess-like" spirit, Aurora looks for the good in all and tries to help others around her. Meanwhile, death and deceit continue to weave it's evil spell. Will Aurora fall victim to the dark side of this new world or will she continue to survive with dignity?
Audience: High School 9-12 to Adult
Strengths: Fast paced and an easy read (less than 100 pgs.). The watercolor illustrations contrast beautifully with the dark storyline. Readers will connect with Princess Aurora and root for her success.
Weaknesses: The story bounces between many characters and does not follow one storyline. Readers may get distracted or even confused. This is a dark story filled with death and decay. It begins with the characters crawling out of a dead child's body and using it as their home and resources. As the story progresses, the child's body begins to decay and rot away. I was not able to make the connection for having this as a part of the story and found it quite disturbing.
Special Considerations: This is considered an "Anti-Fairy Tale." It is dark and unpredictable. It borrows elements of Alice in Wonderland, Jack and the Beanstalk and The Borrowers.
Verdict: Although dark and wrought with death, Beautiful Darkness would make a good addition to the High School library. Students will revisit the Fairy Tale theme and see the characters in a "grown-up" light.
I found this story very disturbing too. The dead child's body, maggots, and characters living inside her eye socket--ick. I couldn't think of who might read this, but I liked your suggestion of a high school class studying fairy tales. When I worked in a high school, the creative writing class had a fairy tale unit and this would have been an interesting addition.
a. Audience for whom the book is written: The book is written for grades 5 and up.
b. Audience to whom it will appeal (might differ from a.) This book appeals to mostly middle school students (in my current school.) I have about three high school students who have checked out the book and these students are in grades 9-10. Having said that, I find this graphic novel interesting and I think adults would enjoy reading it.
The main characters are Fone Bone, and his two cousins, Smiley Bone and Phoney Bone. They are constantly at odds and leave Boneville and end up in a valley that is full of surprises, danger, adventure and friendships.
c. Particular strengths of the book: The illustrations are this books strength. The artwork leaps off the page. It tells the fast paced adventure story in a way that is hard to put the book down. Plus all the creatures they run into and problems they Boney cousins have to solve are unpredictable. This is a book that could be recommended to reluctant readers.
d. Particular weaknesses of the book: The one volume version of Bone is in black and white. The nine volume series is in color. The color version is much more interesting to read.
e. Any special considerations or characteristics: If you have students who are reluctant readers, then I would recommend this series to them. Each books is short and can be read quickly. There is anywhere from two to six frames per page, which makes this an easy, and fun read.
Verdict: I would include this whole series in my collection. ALA has listed it in the top 25 graphic novels for young adults.
Audience: Middle school Appeals to: Grades 6-8. Kids (reluctant readers) interested in graphic novels Strengths: I think each story is intriguing and keeps the reader drawn in. The stories are short, but that's part of the draw. I really like how the last part of the story connects the three. I think readers will connect to the characters because they can relate to them if they look within themselves. Weaknesses: During parts of the "stories" readers might find themselves bored. While the stories are interesting, the monkey king, seemed to drag on. Also, some may have a hard time finding the connection to real life. They just need to push through and it will all come together. Special Considerations: The artwork is wonderful! The stories are funny! Final Verdict: There are a lot of students interested in graphic novels. This is one in which has the visual appeal as well as the readership and it sends a great message. It's a must have in a school library.
I had to pick up this novel when I saw it was a "choose your own adventure" type story. How can a graphic novel have different endings? Jason Shiga pulls it off so well. Advertising over 3000 possible pathways through the story, after a month of causal exploring I have yet to find the elusive "happy" ending, but the journey and the maze of paths is ridiculously enjoyable. How will the world end next time? Just don't pick vanilla!!
Strength: great graphics, awesome use of "pick a path" formatting, introduces audience to concepts such as entropy, causes deeper thinking than the cartoon faces would lead you to believe Weaknesses: some paths are difficult to follow, even with "hints"... Hard to backtrack and "redo" a decision without restarting the whole story. Also includes tough philosophical concepts. No simple "happy" endings
Verdict: jump in and do it! Grab this quirky graphic novel for your shelves - the visual concept, unique layout, and "choose your adventure " format will draw your typical graphic clientele and more as they ponder how to save the world.
It appears that the other readers in class had a differing opinion from me on the age level of this book. Most people thought it would be great for elementary and middle school students, whereas I directed it towards high school students because of my interpretation of the "philosophical" content in the graphic novel. While I do not refute my earlier decision, I confess that the book would have appeal to upper elementary and middle school students, due to the content, graphics, and excitement of the format. Overall, I think readers of all ages will enjoy this graphic novel and be able to gain from it
Title: Spider-Man 2099 by: Peter David Illustrators: Will Sliney and Rick Leonardi Age Recommendation: 12-18 Years Audience to whom it will appeal: 12-15 years old
Strengths of Book: The illustrator's artwork is amazing! He stays true to the Marvel Universe's look and feel. This comic book is not your usual Spider Man comic. Peter Parker is not even the main character in this comic book, which will either be a strength or weakness depending on how you look at it. Miguel O'Hara is the new main character of this graphic novel. He gains similiar powers as the original Spider Man. Miguel's powers are gained through an accident at Alchemax, a chemical company. Near the end of the novel, you see some of the original Marvel Avengers. This was exciting for me since I grew up those comic books.
Weaknesses: Miguel O'Hara. I believe many readers will be disappointed that Peter Parker is not the main character of this graphic novel. Like I said earlier, this may be a strength for regular comic book readers. They might like the change of pace. The action in this graphic novel is pretty tame. I would be comfortable with my 4th grader reading this graphic novel. The older YA would probably look for a graphic novel with more action and more blood.
Verdict: You can add this graphic novel to your library's collection right away. You will not have any arguments from your Middle School parents. This graphic novel is pretty tame. High School students may pass this by due to its tame content.
Title: Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children
By: Ransom Riggs, art by Cassandra Jean
Age recommendation: 13-17
Audience to whom it will appeal: Fans of the book, fans of Tim Burton
Strengths of Book: The graphic incorporates some of the historical photographs used in the novel. The graphic novel brings the story to a higher visual medium by capturing the moments that were imagined by the reader. Like the novel, the graphic also incorporates the vintage photos, the supernatural, and enough plausible reality to make time travel/looping and magical creatures seem real.
Weaknesses of Book: At times the story seems to jump and the reader is left wondering what they missed.
Special Considerations: The imagery is at times difficult to absorb.
Verdict: I would place this book in the media center, but would like to see it at the higher age/grade range in my building (7/8) for checkout. I think the dark context and the imagery may be disturbing and scary for younger readers.
Bone: Old Man's Cave by Jeff Smith
ReplyDeleteThe graphic novel is written for students from grade 3 and up. It is a series of graphic novel and Old Ma's Cave is volume 6 in the series. The graphic novel might be more appealing to young boys and those who love the bone series. The strengths of the graphic novel is that it teaches the reader about unity, family, friendship, loyalty, humor and life lesson. It also an easy read as the graphic novel is divided into chapters. The weakness of the books is that some of the speech bubbles letter type are small especially for the villant in the book. It was a little hard for me to read. ( Must be my old eye). The art work beautiful. The color are vibrant and the illustration of the characters shows shadowing in light and darkness.
Verdict: This would be a huge hit for fan's of Bone series. A must have in graphic novel collection!
Leena
I'm not sure I would have the Bone series in the elementary school. Grades 3 and up? Middle and high school yes. My husband is a huge fan of this series. Our 7 year old was interested in the book. Husband read it long ago and forgot about the sexual tension in Book 1 of Bone seeing Thorn bathing and getting excited about that and of Bone's love interest in Thorn. Ok for secondary level students, but elementary. . . I wouldn't buy it for an elementary media center. That's my only issue with it. Good stories, international popularity--yes, a must-have for secondary media centers.
DeleteInteresting! We have ours in a K-8 building and it is mostly checked out by 3-5th graders.
DeleteI'm in a K-5 building and it is mainly 3-5th graders checking them out. I've had to reorder a brand new set because the series is so popular.
DeleteI love the Bone series. Younger readers would miss the sexual aspect of Bone and Thorn, but they love the potty humor.
DeleteI borrowed BONE from my 3-5 Primary school. It is frequently checked out by students and often challenged by parents. At first, I found it difficult to get into. The story felt complicated at the beginning but as it went on, I found myself getting involved in the plot. I even giggled outloud a few times. All in all, I enjoyed the story more than I thought I would.
DeleteI've been debating about whether Bone is appropriate for my elementary school. I worry because my younger students love checking out the graphic novels. But I also remember my son loving this series in elementary school. Still considering..
DeleteGenre Graphic Novel
ReplyDeleteBook title: Relish: My Life in the Kitchen by Lucy Knisley
a. Audience for whom the book is written.
This book is not kept in the YA section of the library, as it is a graphic novel. It is meant for adults initially, I think. However, I got the title of this book from the ALEX website – an adult book that is also aimed at teens. Really, the sense I get from the author is that it is meant for anyone who loves food, no matter what the age.
b. Audience for whom the book will appeal.
Teens may not gravitate to this book unless they are already into food and food preparation. There is an interesting storyline as the author is telling her life story, highlighting the connection between food and family memories.
c. Strengths
There is humor and honesty in the retelling of her family history. A particular event she shares is about a trip to Mexico when her mom and her mom’s friend got sick as soon as they arrived and spent four days in bed recovering. Meanwhile, the kids were left to fend for themselves, even roaming the streets alone, and later the author recognizes how crazy it sounds for mothers to encourage their preteens to run around a foreign city alone. An additional strength is that this book also comes with a number of recipes also in graphic novel format, which seems to make them more fun and inviting. The author gives suggestions for several of these recipes, so readers can personalize the food to their own tastes. The stories of her childhood, teen years, and young adult years are wound together very thoughtfully and they complement each other nicely.
d. Weaknesses
Being mostly about food, this is a specialized topic and may not get much in the way of usage in every library.
e. Special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.)
The author makes a direct connection between food and family in this text. She demonstrates a love for food and how it’s intertwined in her memories. The reader can certainly learn how to make a few things, the social aspect of food, and a variety of dishes from around the world. There is a distinct message about being open to new experiences and especially foods. Finally, there is encouragement for readers not to worry about perfection.
The artwork is very simple and colorful whether in the narrative portions of the text or in the recipes. The text and storyline are easy to follow.
Within the story of the tip to Mexico, as the kids are exploring the city they find cheap porn and the protagonist’s best friend buys a lot over the course of the four days their mothers are sick. There are some pictures of the covers of these magazines as the author describes their surprise that these magazines are not hidden like they are in the U.S. The drawings are clearly female and nude. Parents may take issue with this depending on where they book is housed and the age of the reader.
f. Your verdict (with details): This is a lovely memoir with an honesty about the author’s past as well as her love for food. The personal stories are entertaining, and the recipes have the potential to get teens into the kitchen. While this book will be enjoyed by a smaller audience, it would be a worthwhile addition to a library.
I love this book, but I read it for myself. I agree with you that it will have a limited audience since it was not originally written for YA readers. However, the right book display can get this one to circulate I'm sure. I think it would be good to let English teachers know about if students have any memoir writing assignments. This would be a good example of one way (one very creative way) to go about it.
DeleteI have also found that there are a number of kids who do like to cook and bake. I think this would definitely be a good one for them. They need to see that there are others with like-minds.
DeleteThe lightning thief by Rick Riodan
ReplyDeleteThis graphic novel is written fro students in grade 5 to grade 9. It would appeal to students who love the Percy Jackson series and love Greek mythology. The strength of the book is that the illustration and coloring of the graphic is totally awesome. The speech bubble changes shapes when there is some action going on with characters. The weakness of the books is that there are too many graphic strips cram in one page. I just wish it was spread a little more. The cover of the books is beautifully done with artwork of the characters of the books such as Percy Jackson and the lightning bolt.
Verdict: If you have the Percy Jackson series, the graphic novel is a must especially a Maud hart Lovelace award winner. It would be a huge it just like the books.
I agree with you on this one. For those kids that love Percy Jackson (and there are many!) this is a great book to add. I like that it might push a kid that read only regular novels to pick up and read a graphic novel. I know some thing graphic novels are simple and easy to read, but I've found them to be more difficult than I thought. And I think that kids feel the same. But having a book that they know just put into graphic form might open them up to this genre and get them reading it more.
DeleteAgreed! This book is wildly popular in my media center because of all the Percy Jackson fans. I think students get a different feel from the graphic novel than they do the book. I only have the first two, but there are students asking me if there are others. There's only four, right?
DeleteSmile, by Raina Telgemeier
ReplyDeleteThis graphic novel is listed for Grade 5 and up. I would agree that this is an appropriate age, all the way up to adults, who will enjoy reminiscing of what it was like to be a teen in the 90's. The only inappropriate content for 5th graders is that Raina's friends play spin-the-bottle at a party during their 8th grade year.
Strengths of the book are in the comic-style artwork, often humorous at times, as well as the truth in story-telling for a self-proclaimed "nerdy" teen who is easily relatable to readers. Teen girls especially will be able to relate to Raina's beauty struggles, orthodontic trauma, and various other scenes involving friends, dating and career aspirations.
Weaknesses are in the drastic age progression from middle school through high school; that as she gets older, there are more party and dating references, such as playing spin the bottle. Also, there are large jumps in time that may confuse younger readers.
Special considerations include the comic-style artwork, the setting in San Francisco, as well as the fact that Raina herself is the protagonist in the story.
Verdict: A delightful read for middle and high school audiences, both male and female. You will likely need multiple copies on hand to meet demand.
This graphic novel works in elementary, too. My 4th and 5th grade students LOVE this book and the others from this author. The spin-the-bottle game isn't risqué or anything. The same type of stuff is in movies for kids this age. Most can handle it.
DeleteMy daughter (grade 5) has read this numerous times and loves it. In fact, I was thinking of picking it up as my choice book (but think I will now do "Sisters" -also by R. Telgemeier- instead.) I wasn't sure if it was a little too "young" for the YA lit category, so glad to read your assessment of it.
DeleteFirst published as a monthly serial DC comic Vertigo imprint in 1988, the Sandman by Neil Gaiman and illustrated by Sam Kieth, Mike Dringenberg, Jill Thompson, et al. is a dark, urban fantasy novel in graphic format that explores the metaphysical topics in the realm of dreams. It has achieved a cult classic status and is arguably a valuable and collectible work. The intended audience for this collection is the mature comic book fan, older teens through adults. I believe this collection, now 27 years old, still appeals to true fans of the comic/graphic novel community (mostly male); however, given the expansion of the format (graphic novels are a format, not a genre) and with that, the broadening of the audience, Sandman will appeal to a number of individuals who enjoy fantasy, gothic horror, and mythopoetic narratives.
ReplyDeleteThe strength of the Sandman series is the intrigue of the Sandman, the Lord of Dreams, himself. This character is Gaiman’s own reimagining of an old DC comic character long forgotten by the late 1980s when Gaiman summoned this immortal being into literary existence. One need not be acquainted with the stories of the past to immediately get sucked into this new rendition and its opening scene of an occult ceremony in an English manor house, circa 1925. In addition to excellent character development, a sophisticated plot sprinkled with literary and historical references, the art work is phenomenal. Pages explode with action and present various viewpoints; there are no boring or formulaic layouts. The riveting presentation engages the reader throughout the narrative. Dave McKean’s cover art for each installment is eerie and fantastical—smoky mirrors, death masks, and murky laboratory jars filled with various specimens. These elements help to conjure up a supernatural atmosphere and a feeling of suspended animation and paralyzing fear one associates with nightmares.
There are references to other DC comic characters and plots that the uninitiated will not catch, but these small gaps do not interfere holistically with the story telling. Another possible weakness may be found in the lack of foreshadowing regarding the Sandman’s sibling in the few scenes where the Sandman’s dreamers die during the first eight issues of the series, now bound as a collection titled Preludes and Nocturnes.
Special considerations: Gaiman is no amateur. He is a master storyteller, poetic, and clever in his references to literary figures Biblical and otherwise. This text is not for the causal reader, nor the faint of heart. It is full of gruesome imagery and diabolical situations. There is sex; there is violence; and the presentation is unapologetic. We are talking heaven and hell here, and the marriage of art and narrative that makes this series explode is amazing and sophisticated.
Verdict: As a K-12 library media specialist, I cannot in good conscious recommend this series to a minor. I cannot imagine the series in an elementary or middle school, and would be surprised to find it in a high school. I believe Gaiman’s intended audience was the adult comic fan base; and as a result of the quality and popularity of his work, the Sandman series has gained a devoted fan base of younger readers. I am ok with that. Readers who crave this type of narrative will find this series, but I personally do not feel compelled to actively promote or guide anyone under age 18 to this series.
Agreed! College level...
DeleteJenny - I had this book as one of my choices but put it aside. It seemed too dark for my liking. I'm glad you read it and offered a review.
Delete“This One Summer” by Jillian Tamaki & Mariko Tamaki
ReplyDelete“This One Summer” is a graphic novel about the transition from child to young adult. This quiet book is written for teens and preteens. Older teens may be put off by the younger characters. Preteens that are ready to read about the older topics such as sex, drinking, teen pregnancy, and depression may also choose this to read. I think it will appeal to girls more than boys due to it’s purple cover, pink spine, and female main characters. It would also appeal to reluctant readers.
Strengths:
The biggest strengths in this graphic novel are the illustrations. The illustrator portrays the very real emotions of each character in a quiet, yet poignant way. I am amazed how much emotion can be seen in two-color illustrations. I also thought the characters felt very real. Like this is exactly what girls this age would be doing and how they would be acting. Rose was a slob and very overdramatic. I felt like her reactions were spot on.
Weaknesses:
One of the reasons I am not a huge fan of graphic novels is because I want more story. It’s just not enough for me. I felt the same way with this one especially since there was very little plot. It was a very quiet glimpse of a girl’s summer. It showed more character development than story.
Verdict: I think this graphic novel would be an appropriate purchase for both middle and high school libraries. The artwork is beautiful and expressive. It would be a good “next step” for students that enjoyed graphic novels like “Smile” and “Sisters” when they were younger.
I too read this book, and I agree about the way she portrays emotions in a very poignant way and was also surprised at the emotion that was conveyed in two-color illustrations.
DeleteI also read this book and agreed that I wanted more at the end. I waiting for something to happen, something more, some twist, something!
DeleteI read this one, too. I agree. The illustrations are wonderful! I thought it was a good story. One of which, many could relate to. I remember being a young girl and feeling many of the same things as Rose and Windy. I could also relate to the mother in the story. I think all of can connect to the story in our own way. We often judge people from the outside, without knowing their "story." I think this book is filled with that. Again, I agree. I was hoping for more at the end, also. I think this book would be a great fit in the middle school or high school.
DeleteI Remember Beirut by Zeina Abirached
ReplyDeleteGrades 6 and up--
This stunning graphic novel is compact, but powerful. The artwork is similar to the stark black and white drawings of Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis and illustrate the divided world in which she lives: Beirut, Lebanon in the 1980s and 1990s. Written like a list poem, with each page or so beginning with “I Remember,” Abirached tells the story of her life growing up in a war zone.
Intended audience: Young adults interested in history.
Audience to whom it may appeal: I think this book could appeal to upper elementary students to grandparents, of all genders, races and religions. Its universal themes of memory and perseverance through struggle have the potential to provide connections for many.
Strengths: The artwork is visually very appealing. The solid black and white images are simple but captivating. The poetic style and repetition makes it accessible for a wider variety of audiences.
Weaknesses: Without much historical context, this book might be hard to understand, but it can also stand on its own as a story of a young girl’s life and all of the things she experienced. Although the prose and dialogue are relatively simplistic, there are historical and cultural references that will likely be missed by students with little background knowledge.
Special considerations: The book is a companion to A Game for Swallows which focuses on one particular night during war time.
VERDICT: This book would make a great addition to either the graphic novel or history section of any upper elementary through high school media center. The accessible format will appeal to lower readers, while the historical content might entice higher level readers to try a new format: graphic novel.
Title: El Deafo
ReplyDeleteAuthor: CeCe Bell
I've had this book sitting on my shelf for a little bit. The other night I was going through my books and saw. It looked quick, and I knew it had been a Newbery Honor book, so I decided it was time to read it. 3 hours later I had finished it!
It was really good. I loved how it gave an inside view of how it feels to been seen as different and how much she just wanted to be seen as just like everyone else. I mean we all know this, but this story gave me a glimpse at the inner dialog of a young girl going growing up feeling that way. It truly helped me gain a clearer understanding.
I've had students that use the amplifier talked about in the book. So the whole part of the story where Cece can hear the teacher using it even when she's out of the classroom made me giggle because we were told to make sure to turn it off for certain situations. Using the bathroom was one situation we were told clearly to make sure we turned it off! So when Cece can hear her teacher in the bathroom, it really made me giggle!
This is a book I could see myself recommending to many middle schoolers. It had a good message, it is semi-autobiographical, it is funny, and it has a good message. Having a book that combines all that is wonderful because kids will enjoy the story and walk away with better understanding of the people around them. PLUS - they can relate to Cece just wanting to have a good friend. Aren't all middle schoolers looking for that? I couldn't ask for anything more.
Final thought: Quick, fun and teachable but completely relatable. One that I would for sure add to my media center.
Jill - I read El Deafo last summer and instantly connected with CeCe. As a classroom teacher, I often wore the special mic that went directly to a student's ear piece. And, sadly, I am also guilty of forgetting to turn it off. I accidentally purchased it for my K-2 school last year. After reading it, I felt it would get more attention at the 3-5 elementary.
DeleteI laughed at the part where the teacher forgot to turn the mic off too because it happens all the time at my school! Elementary kids enjoy this story too. I have it in my K-5 school.
DeleteSisters- by Raina Talgemeier
ReplyDeleteOne of the reasons I wanted to read Sisters is to find out what all the fuss was about among my daughter and her friends. At last year’s school book fair, she just HAD to have it (along with Smile, also by Talgemeier—see Mandy’s blog post.) The audience is upper elementary to middle school. It would appeal to grades 4-6 in particular, I believe, though readers all the way through high school may enjoy it for a quick, easy read. The main character, Raina, is preparing for the transition to high school, which is another factor that could expand the audience to high school. I found no “inappropriate” content or anything remotely “challenge-able” in the book.
Strengths of the book are its fast pace (again, for those looking for a quick easy read.) Something to note, however, is that even with its fast pace, some bigger topics are explored, such as family dynamics, family change, and job loss. The way these bigger issues are discussed is lighthearted enough so that students who do not necessarily want an overly emotional read will find that Sisters meets that criteria. Raina has an authentic voice, and the sibling rivalry/ bickering is portrayed in a way that most readers (with siblings, that is) will likely find relatable.
Weaknesses: The story jumps from past to present in a way that is not always seamless. Overall, the technique of jumping from past to present adds to the story—and is integral to the story, I might add-- but in a couple instances, the transition is clumsy and may be difficult for younger or struggling readers to follow.
Special considerations: The road trip is a central component of the story, and the geographical information is an added bonus. The family has some “unfortunate” luck with pets, which Talgemeier weaves throughout the story. There is a mention of possible divorce, and the sisters grapple with this possibility. Again, it is mentioned and comes out more as a minor detail in the end, but gives the story just enough depth to encourage some thought about our own families (e.g.- What does it mean when parents fight? How does a job loss affect a relationship? etc.)
Verdict: I would include multiple copies in any elementary or middle school library. I would include it in a high school library as well, but with fewer copies than at the younger grades. While it will likely appeal more to female students, some male students will read Sisters as well.
"The Graveyard Book" by Neil Gaiman
ReplyDeleteThis book would appeal to middle school students both boys and girls alike. I would recommend this book to students that like fantasy novels set in another world and are looking for a good creepy ghost story.
Strengths:
Once you get past the murder scene on the first page you find that The Graveyard Book could really act as a metaphor about growing up. As kids grow up they learn about the "outside" world beyond their protective homes and begin to have curious questions and what life is really life. Bod (short for Nobody) is the protagonist in the book who is taken in by ghosts in the graveyard as he is left with no one to look after him when his family is murdered. As he grows up he begins to have ambitions to explore beyond the graveyard walls.
Weaknesses:
The title and the cover of the book should prepare the reader for a creepy story. However, if those signals were not caught in the title and front cover of the book the first page could be a bit much for a child not expecting such a squeamish story. If you do get past the first page there is nothing else as squeamish besides the spookiness of ghosts, vampire-like characters, monsters, and a creepy setting of a graveyard and a little boy being raised by ghosts. If a reader is looking for these things they will LOVE this book.
Verdict:
I would include a few copies in the middle school collection for those into ghost stories. The murder of Bod's family is the first page of the book, but it is immediate and what is left is a fantasy novel that will appeal to girls and boys alike looking for a ghost story.
I read the Graveyard Book - Volume 1
DeleteThis graphic novel holds its own against the full version of the book (which won the Newbery Award in 2009). For many readers, the graphic depictions may clear up some confusing aspects of the written word while adding a touch of humor but it also takes away some of the mystery. For example, at the start of the novel, it isn’t completely clear what type of creature Silas is; but when he first appears in the graphic novel (including the cover), there is no doubt. The reader loses out on a delicious moment of tension and wonder due to the clear visual presentation. On the other hand, there are elements in the graphic novel that benefit from the illustrations such as the descent into the world of the ghouls and the dance Macabray.
The Library Journal Review indicates that this title is for grades 5 and up. I can see the appeal of this graphic novel extending to lower grade levels for students who like ghost stories and spooky content but would caution its inclusion in an elementary library due to an opening bloody scene that may give younger students nightmares if they happen to pull it off the shelf and glance through the illustrations (special consideration).
The strength of this graphic novel lies in the fact that Gaiman is an expert storyteller and has first class illustrators to help him tell his tale. The pictures and the supporting dialogue/explanations are a combination of complex and simple words. A striving reader will find guidance in the illustrations if they struggle with the wording while at the same time, confusing illustrations are clarified through the descriptive wording.
Another strength lies in the fact that each chapter is like a short story that builds to a problematic climax and finds resolution. Although the overall story builds from chapter to chapter, a reader can enjoy the graphic novel in short installments. This also allows for the original novel to be split into two graphic novels – a point of consideration for the media specialist. There is much talk about Gaiman writing a follow-up to the Graveyard Book and some readers of the original book may think that the 2nd Volume of the graphic novel is that long awaited follow-up. Be prepared to help student overcome disappointment but make sure you order both volumes!
A weakness may be found in the complexity of the story. The character of the Man Jack is mysterious even in the full novel version of this tale. The graphic novel does nothing to clarify this mystery and may leave some readers confused (thus the desire by many to have a follow up novel to The Graveyard Book).
Verdict: This is a must have graphic novel for middle school and high school media centers. There is depth and intrigue to the story while at the same time a simplicity in each "short story" chapter of Bod’s life in the graveyard. Multiple levels of readers will find this graphic novel enjoyable giving it broad appeal, ensuring that it will receive good circulation.
I also read this book and found I enjoyed the graphic more than the novel. The strengths of the graphic are definitely in the pictures that bring the characters and scenes to life. I agree that the first images are tough to look at and I found myself quickly skipping over them. The content of the story is very thick and leaves the reader wanting to know more. My inherited media center collection has both copies of the graphic novels and 4 copies of the novel. The graphics are checked out with more frequency than the novel. I would include this book in the collection due to it's visual storytelling appeal and scary subject nature which seems to be a good sell to most middle school readers.
DeleteBoxers & Saints by Gene Luen Yang (2 graphic novels - they come as a set)
ReplyDeleteGenre: Graphic Novel - Historical
Pages: Boxers - 325 / Saints - 170
Published: 2013 by First Second
Boxers is about Bao, a chinese son, who learns a special ritual that gives him the strength to slay his enemies. On his journey to save China, he meets a woman and falls in love. He eventually becomes the leader of the Society of Righteous and Harmonious Fists and leads the organization to the Chinese capital.
Saints is about Four-Girl, a chinese daughter, who is constantly belittled and mistreated as a child. In her suffering, she decides to live up to those expectations and take up the challenge of becoming a “devil.” This path leads her to convert to the Christian faith. As a Christian in China, she is forced to move into a more isolated village with other Christians. Eventually, the Society of Righteous and Harmonious Fists attack her church.
Audience:
These books could be read by anyone age twelve and up. Some of the vocabulary is difficult and culturally specific, but a student could still understand the story without those words. The fact that it is a graphic novel also makes it of interest to younger readers and even struggling readers.
Strengths:
As a set, Boxers and Saints gives two sides of a violent and religiously extreme historical event. The story is set in China during the Boxer Rebellion, in which a secret Chinese organization led a rebellious uprising against western and Japanese influences. These graphic novels give history a touch of emotion and an adventurous backstory.
In Boxers, Bao has the best intentions behind his actions. But sometimes, those intentions lead him into doing horrifying acts. His remorse and guilt haunt his dreams. It is very apparent that he struggles between the rights and wrong of the uprising. Bao’s love interest is a very strong female character. She takes up her sword despite all the negative doubters.
In Saints, you connect and sympathize with Four-Girl from the very beginning of the book.This is the hook for readers to continue reading and stay engaged in the story to the very end.
Weaknesses:
Both reads are so short and leave you wanting to know more. There are a few times when you think that a part of the storyline will lead to something larger, but it doesn’t. There just isn’t enough room in a graphic novel to fit all the tiny details and subplots.
Special Considerations:
In Boxers, Bao’s father gets beat up by western officers to the point where he becomes mute and lethargic. There is also quite a bit of violence, killing, and death by sword. A severed human head is depicted as a sign of battle victory. A mother is murdered in front of her daughter and granddaughter.
In Saints, Four-Girl has suicidal thoughts at the age of eight and thinks of herself as a devil. She also endures physical and verbal abuse from her grandfather, uncle, and mother. There is also a character that murders a man and then is attacked by someone who uses a knife to slice whiskers into his cheeks.
Verdict:
Gene Luen Yang has created a fictionalized and accurate retelling of the Boxer Rebellion. The graphic novels come together flawlessly to paint a clear picture of what it meant to be on either side of this uprising. Readers are left with an understanding that there are no winners when it comes to violence such as this. This historical graphic novel set is a must-have in middle and high school media centers - make sure to purchase them as a set.
My daughter who is a huge history buff was interested in these when we met Gene. She has them, but I don't know if she has read them yet. Thanks for sharing your views on them. I never thought about whether I'd put them in the media center, and your review has put my mind thinking about them in that way.
DeleteBeautiful Darkness
ReplyDeleteBy Fabien Vehlmann & Kerrascoet
Genre: Graphic Novel - Fantasy
Published 2014 (originally in French then translated)
A twist of a fairy tale where good vs. evil is not always obvious. Princess Aurora is swept away from the comforts of home to a dream-like land where she is forced to survive. In her typical "princess-like" spirit, Aurora looks for the good in all and tries to help others around her. Meanwhile, death and deceit continue to weave it's evil spell. Will Aurora fall victim to the dark side of this new world or will she continue to survive with dignity?
Audience: High School 9-12 to Adult
Strengths:
Fast paced and an easy read (less than 100 pgs.). The watercolor illustrations contrast beautifully with the dark storyline. Readers will connect with Princess Aurora and root for her success.
Weaknesses:
The story bounces between many characters and does not follow one storyline. Readers may get distracted or even confused. This is a dark story filled with death and decay. It begins with the characters crawling out of a dead child's body and using it as their home and resources. As the story progresses, the child's body begins to decay and rot away. I was not able to make the connection for having this as a part of the story and found it quite disturbing.
Special Considerations:
This is considered an "Anti-Fairy Tale." It is dark and unpredictable. It borrows elements of Alice in Wonderland, Jack and the Beanstalk and The Borrowers.
Verdict:
Although dark and wrought with death, Beautiful Darkness would make a good addition to the High School library. Students will revisit the Fairy Tale theme and see the characters in a "grown-up" light.
I found this story very disturbing too. The dead child's body, maggots, and characters living inside her eye socket--ick. I couldn't think of who might read this, but I liked your suggestion of a high school class studying fairy tales. When I worked in a high school, the creative writing class had a fairy tale unit and this would have been an interesting addition.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteBone
ReplyDeleteBy Jeff Smith
a. Audience for whom the book is written:
The book is written for grades 5 and up.
b. Audience to whom it will appeal (might differ from a.)
This book appeals to mostly middle school students (in my current school.) I have about three high school students who have checked out the book and these students are in grades 9-10. Having said that, I find this graphic novel interesting and I think adults would enjoy reading it.
The main characters are Fone Bone, and his two cousins, Smiley Bone and Phoney Bone. They are constantly at odds and leave Boneville and end up in a valley that is full of surprises, danger, adventure and friendships.
c. Particular strengths of the book:
The illustrations are this books strength. The artwork leaps off the page. It tells the fast paced adventure story in a way that is hard to put the book down. Plus all the creatures they run into and problems they Boney cousins have to solve are unpredictable. This is a book that could be recommended to reluctant readers.
d. Particular weaknesses of the book:
The one volume version of Bone is in black and white. The nine volume series is in color. The color version is much more interesting to read.
e. Any special considerations or characteristics:
If you have students who are reluctant readers, then I would recommend this series to them. Each books is short and can be read quickly. There is anywhere from two to six frames per page, which makes this an easy, and fun read.
Verdict: I would include this whole series in my collection. ALA has listed it in the top 25 graphic novels for young adults.
American Born Chinese
ReplyDeleteby: Gene Luen Yang
Audience: Middle school
Appeals to: Grades 6-8. Kids (reluctant readers) interested in graphic novels
Strengths: I think each story is intriguing and keeps the reader drawn in. The stories are short, but that's part of the draw. I really like how the last part of the story connects the three. I think readers will connect to the characters because they can relate to them if they look within themselves.
Weaknesses: During parts of the "stories" readers might find themselves bored. While the stories are interesting, the monkey king, seemed to drag on. Also, some may have a hard time finding the connection to real life. They just need to push through and it will all come together.
Special Considerations: The artwork is wonderful! The stories are funny!
Final Verdict: There are a lot of students interested in graphic novels. This is one in which has the visual appeal as well as the readership and it sends a great message. It's a must have in a school library.
Meanwhile: pick any path by Jason Shiga
ReplyDeleteAudience: high school, "philosophical " types
I had to pick up this novel when I saw it was a "choose your own adventure" type story. How can a graphic novel have different endings? Jason Shiga pulls it off so well. Advertising over 3000 possible pathways through the story, after a month of causal exploring I have yet to find the elusive "happy" ending, but the journey and the maze of paths is ridiculously enjoyable. How will the world end next time? Just don't pick vanilla!!
Strength: great graphics, awesome use of "pick a path" formatting, introduces audience to concepts such as entropy, causes deeper thinking than the cartoon faces would lead you to believe
Weaknesses: some paths are difficult to follow, even with "hints"... Hard to backtrack and "redo" a decision without restarting the whole story. Also includes tough philosophical concepts. No simple "happy" endings
Verdict: jump in and do it! Grab this quirky graphic novel for your shelves - the visual concept, unique layout, and "choose your adventure " format will draw your typical graphic clientele and more as they ponder how to save the world.
It appears that the other readers in class had a differing opinion from me on the age level of this book. Most people thought it would be great for elementary and middle school students, whereas I directed it towards high school students because of my interpretation of the "philosophical" content in the graphic novel. While I do not refute my earlier decision, I confess that the book would have appeal to upper elementary and middle school students, due to the content, graphics, and excitement of the format. Overall, I think readers of all ages will enjoy this graphic novel and be able to gain from it
DeleteTitle: Spider-Man 2099 by: Peter David Illustrators: Will Sliney and Rick Leonardi
ReplyDeleteAge Recommendation: 12-18 Years
Audience to whom it will appeal: 12-15 years old
Strengths of Book: The illustrator's artwork is amazing! He stays true to the Marvel Universe's look and feel. This comic book is not your usual Spider Man comic. Peter Parker is not even the main character in this comic book, which will either be a strength or weakness depending on how you look at it. Miguel O'Hara is the new main character of this graphic novel. He gains similiar powers as the original Spider Man. Miguel's powers are gained through an accident at Alchemax, a chemical company. Near the end of the novel, you see some of the original Marvel Avengers. This was exciting for me since I grew up those comic books.
Weaknesses: Miguel O'Hara. I believe many readers will be disappointed that Peter Parker is not the main character of this graphic novel. Like I said earlier, this may be a strength for regular comic book readers. They might like the change of pace. The action in this graphic novel is pretty tame. I would be comfortable with my 4th grader reading this graphic novel. The older YA would probably look for a graphic novel with more action and more blood.
Verdict: You can add this graphic novel to your library's collection right away. You will not have any arguments from your Middle School parents. This graphic novel is pretty tame. High School students may pass this by due to its tame content.
Title: Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children
ReplyDeleteBy: Ransom Riggs, art by Cassandra Jean
Age recommendation: 13-17
Audience to whom it will appeal: Fans of the book, fans of Tim Burton
Strengths of Book: The graphic incorporates some of the historical photographs used in the novel. The graphic novel brings the story to a higher visual medium by capturing the moments that were imagined by the reader. Like the novel, the graphic also incorporates the vintage photos, the supernatural, and enough plausible reality to make time travel/looping and magical creatures seem real.
Weaknesses of Book: At times the story seems to jump and the reader is left wondering what they missed.
Special Considerations: The imagery is at times difficult to absorb.
Verdict: I would place this book in the media center, but would like to see it at the higher age/grade range in my building (7/8) for checkout. I think the dark context and the imagery may be disturbing and scary for younger readers.